UPSC CSE 2026 Essay Paper Discussion

Mains 2026 · Practice archive

PSIR Optional Paper II practice questions for UPSC Mains 2026.

28 questionsModel outlines included
Q.110 marks · 150w 9 min Medium

Criticism of the institutional approach in comparative political analysis has come up in successive waves. Comment.

Subtopic: Paper II · Successive waves of criticism of the institutional approach

Show model answer outline

Describe old institutionalism, then take the criticism in three named waves, ending with the new institutionalist recovery.

Key points
  • The old institutional approach studied constitutions, legislatures, executives and courts through legal-formal and historical-descriptive methods.
  • First wave — behaviouralism (1950s-60s).
  • Second wave — the developing world and systems theory.
  • Third wave — political economy and the state.

Open full model answer →

Q.210 marks · 150w 9 min Medium

Extractive capitalism

Subtopic: Paper II · Extractive capitalism

Show model answer outline

Define it, distinguish it from productive capitalism, give its forms including the data variant, then the consequences.

Key points
  • Classical extractivism — mining, oil, timber and plantation economies, historically organised through colonial rule and continuing as commodity dependence in the global South.
  • Neo-extractivism — the Latin American pattern in which even left governments funded social spending from commodity exports, and so stayed locked into the same model.
  • Financial extraction — value stripped through debt, asset sales and shareholder payouts rather than investment.
  • Data extraction — Shoshana Zuboff's surveillance capitalism, where behavioural surplus is taken from users without compensation and sold as prediction.

Open full model answer →

Q.310 marks · 150w 9 min Medium

Discuss various methods of Balance of Power.

Subtopic: Paper II · Methods of the Balance of Power

Show model answer outline

List Morgenthau's classical devices, then add the structural distinction between internal and external balancing.

Key points
  • Divide and rule — keeping potential rivals weak by keeping them separated, as France did towards the German states for centuries.
  • Compensations — territorial or colonial compensation to preserve relative shares, as in the eighteenth-century partitions of Poland and the African partition at the Berlin Conference.
  • Armaments — building military strength, which produces the security dilemma and arms races.
  • Alliances — the most important method, in which a state adds another's capabilities to its own.
  • The balancer or holder of the balance — a state outside the contending groups, throwing its weight against whichever side threatens to dominate, the classic British role.

Open full model answer →

Q.410 marks · 150w 9 min Medium

Clientilism

Subtopic: Paper II · Clientelism

Show model answer outline

Define the exchange, give its defining features, distinguish it from programmatic politics and corruption, then the Indian evidence.

Key points
  • From programmatic politics, where benefits follow published rules and reach recipients whether or not they voted for the government.
  • From corruption, which is private appropriation; clientelism redistributes to a constituency, which is why it can be electorally popular.
  • From pork-barrel politics, which targets districts rather than identified individuals.

Open full model answer →

Q.510 marks · 150w 9 min Medium

What role does identity and technology play in the conceptualisation of Defensive realism ?

Subtopic: Paper II · Identity and technology in defensive realism

Show model answer outline

State the defensive realist core, then show technology entering through the offence-defence balance and identity through perceived intent.

Key points
  • Defensive realism holds that the international system rewards moderation: states seek an appropriate amount of power, not the maximum, because excessive expansion provokes balancing and is self-defeating.
  • Technology enters through the offence-defence balance.
  • Identity enters through perceived intent.

Open full model answer →

Q.610 marks · 150w 9 min Medium

Describe India’s objections to agricultural negotiations at the World Trade Organisation.

Subtopic: Paper II · India's objections in WTO agriculture negotiations

Show model answer outline

Anchor in the Agreement on Agriculture, then take the objections one by one as structural asymmetries, then India's demands.

Key points
  • A reference price frozen in the past. Domestic support is measured against an external reference price fixed at 1986-88 levels with no inflation adjustment, so support stable in real terms appears to breach limits simply because prices have since risen.
  • Asymmetric entitlements. The de minimis allowance is 10 per cent of production value for developing countries and 5 per cent for developed ones, but the latter also hold large historical Aggregate Measurement of Support entitlements India never had.
  • The Green Box loophole. Support classified as minimally trade-distorting is unlimited, and developed countries simply reclassified their support into it as direct payments.
  • Public stockholding. Procurement at minimum support prices for the public distribution system is counted as trade-distorting. The Bali decision of 2013 gave an interim peace clause; the permanent solution India seeks is still not agreed.
  • No Special Safeguard Mechanism against import surges and price collapses.

Open full model answer →

Q.710 marks · 150w 9 min Medium

What strategic options can India exercise as a response to the tensions between Pakistan and Afghanistan ?

Subtopic: Paper II · India's strategic options amid Pakistan-Afghanistan tensions

Show model answer outline

Explain why the tension is structural, then set out options by instrument, then state the limits honestly.

Key points
  • Calibrated engagement without recognition. India reopened a technical mission in Kabul in 2022; engagement preserves access and intelligence without conferring legitimacy.
  • Humanitarian and development leverage. Wheat, medicines and vaccines, and the goodwill of completed projects — the Afghan-India Friendship Dam, the Zaranj-Delaram highway and the parliament building.
  • Connectivity that bypasses Pakistan. Chabahar port and the International North-South Transport Corridor make trade with Afghanistan and Central Asia independent of Pakistani transit — the most durable structural response.
  • Counter-terrorism vigilance, since anti-India groups have historically used Afghan territory.
  • Regional coordination with Iran, Russia and the Central Asian states.

Open full model answer →

Q.810 marks · 150w 9 min Medium

Discuss the three areas of security co-operation between India and Israel.

Subtopic: Paper II · Three areas of India-Israel security cooperation

Show model answer outline

Take defence technology, counter-terrorism and homeland security, and cyber, with named systems and agreements in each.

Key points
  • Air defence: the Barak-8 medium-range surface-to-air missile, co-developed by Israel Aerospace Industries with the DRDO, and its naval and army variants.
  • Airborne surveillance: Phalcon airborne early warning radars mounted on Il-76 platforms.
  • Unmanned systems: Searcher and Heron series drones, now supplemented by domestic assembly.
  • Precision munitions and anti-tank capability, including Spike missiles.
  • Manufacturing partnerships under Make in India, including joint ventures for missile subsystems and a drone production facility in Hyderabad.

Open full model answer →

Q.910 marks · 150w 9 min Medium

Discuss the main features of the land-boundary agreement between India and Bangladesh.

Subtopic: Paper II · Main features of the India-Bangladesh Land Boundary Agreement

Show model answer outline

Give the legal chain from 1974 to 2015, then the three components of the settlement with figures, then its significance.

Key points
  • Exchange of enclaves — islands of one country's territory entirely surrounded by the other, a legacy of pre-colonial princely arrangements. India transferred 111 enclaves of about 17,160 acres to Bangladesh and received 51 enclaves of about 7,110 acres, ceding more than it gained.
  • Adverse possessions — areas administered by one country but legally belonging to the other, regularised in line with actual occupation.
  • Demarcation of the remaining undemarcated stretches in three sectors, completing a boundary of about 4,096 kilometres.

Open full model answer →

Q.1010 marks · 150w 9 min Medium

Analyse the relevance of India-Brazil economic co-operation in strengthening the bilateral relations between the two countries.

Subtopic: Paper II · India-Brazil economic cooperation and the bilateral relationship

Show model answer outline

State why the relationship needs an economic base, give the sectors, then the constraints and what would fix them.

Key points
  • Energy and biofuels. Brazil's sugarcane ethanol programme is the world's oldest at scale and India's blending drive among the fastest growing; the Global Biofuel Alliance launched at the Delhi G-20 in 2023 institutionalises this.
  • Agriculture. Brazil supplies soyabean oil and pulses, but the two compete in sugar, so cooperation must be negotiated rather than assumed.
  • Pharmaceuticals. Indian generics have a large Brazilian market, and both defended intellectual property flexibilities during the pandemic.
  • Defence, where Embraer's presence in India gives a base for co-production.
  • Trade architecture. The India-Mercosur preferential agreement covers a narrow list; widening it is the largest available gain.

Open full model answer →