UPSC CSE 2026 Essay Paper Discussion
PSIR Optional Paper II 10 marks · 150w 9 min Medium

Discuss various methods of Balance of Power.

Subtopic: Paper II · Methods of the Balance of Power

Model answer outline

How to structure your answer

List Morgenthau's classical devices, then add the structural distinction between internal and external balancing.

Full model answer

Detailed model answer

208 words · target 150 words · 9 min

Balance of power is both a condition and a policy; the methods are the means by which states prevent any one power from achieving preponderance.

Morgenthau's classical devices in Politics Among Nations (1948):

  • Divide and rule — keeping potential rivals weak by keeping them separated, as France did towards the German states for centuries.
  • Compensations — territorial or colonial compensation to preserve relative shares, as in the eighteenth-century partitions of Poland and the African partition at the Berlin Conference.
  • Armaments — building military strength, which produces the security dilemma and arms races.
  • Alliances — the most important method, in which a state adds another's capabilities to its own.
  • The balancer or holder of the balance — a state outside the contending groups, throwing its weight against whichever side threatens to dominate, the classic British role.

The structural restatement. Waltz distinguishes internal balancing — increasing one's own economic and military capability, which he considers more reliable — from external balancing, or alliance formation. Balancing is contrasted with bandwagoning, joining the stronger side, which Waltz holds is rarer than expected; Schweller argues it is common when the motive is profit rather than security.

Contemporary variants. Soft balancing through institutions, law and diplomacy without military confrontation, and multi-alignment, which India practises to avoid a binding choice among great powers.

Key points

What an examiner expects to see

  • Divide and rule — keeping potential rivals weak by keeping them separated, as France did towards the German states for centuries.
  • Compensations — territorial or colonial compensation to preserve relative shares, as in the eighteenth-century partitions of Poland and the African partition at the Berlin Conference.
  • Armaments — building military strength, which produces the security dilemma and arms races.
  • Alliances — the most important method, in which a state adds another's capabilities to its own.
  • The balancer or holder of the balance — a state outside the contending groups, throwing its weight against whichever side threatens to dominate, the classic British role.

Share this answer