Discuss various methods of Balance of Power.
Subtopic: Paper II · Methods of the Balance of Power
How to structure your answer
List Morgenthau's classical devices, then add the structural distinction between internal and external balancing.
Detailed model answer
208 words · target 150 words · 9 min
Balance of power is both a condition and a policy; the methods are the means by which states prevent any one power from achieving preponderance.
Morgenthau's classical devices in Politics Among Nations (1948):
- Divide and rule — keeping potential rivals weak by keeping them separated, as France did towards the German states for centuries.
- Compensations — territorial or colonial compensation to preserve relative shares, as in the eighteenth-century partitions of Poland and the African partition at the Berlin Conference.
- Armaments — building military strength, which produces the security dilemma and arms races.
- Alliances — the most important method, in which a state adds another's capabilities to its own.
- The balancer or holder of the balance — a state outside the contending groups, throwing its weight against whichever side threatens to dominate, the classic British role.
The structural restatement. Waltz distinguishes internal balancing — increasing one's own economic and military capability, which he considers more reliable — from external balancing, or alliance formation. Balancing is contrasted with bandwagoning, joining the stronger side, which Waltz holds is rarer than expected; Schweller argues it is common when the motive is profit rather than security.
Contemporary variants. Soft balancing through institutions, law and diplomacy without military confrontation, and multi-alignment, which India practises to avoid a binding choice among great powers.
What an examiner expects to see
- Divide and rule — keeping potential rivals weak by keeping them separated, as France did towards the German states for centuries.
- Compensations — territorial or colonial compensation to preserve relative shares, as in the eighteenth-century partitions of Poland and the African partition at the Berlin Conference.
- Armaments — building military strength, which produces the security dilemma and arms races.
- Alliances — the most important method, in which a state adds another's capabilities to its own.
- The balancer or holder of the balance — a state outside the contending groups, throwing its weight against whichever side threatens to dominate, the classic British role.