Opens in a new tab
Join Anantam IAS Channel on Telegram

Privacy vs press freedom: where should the line be drawn?

Why in news?

Digital News Publishers Association has challenged the DPDP Act, 2023 in the Supreme Court for lacking a journalistic exemption.

UPSC Relevance

Prelims – Article 19(1)(a), Article 19(2), Article 21, DPDP Act, 2023, RTI Act, 2005, landmark judgments

Mains, GS2 – Indian Constitution: significant provisions and basic structure; Transparency and accountability

The issue in brief

  • The Digital News Publishers Association (DNPA), a body of the digital arms of 21 news publishers, has challenged several provisions of the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023 and the DPDP Rules, 2025.
  • Core complaint: The Act has no exemption for journalism. The draft Bills of 2018, 2019 and 2021 had one. It was dropped in the 2022 draft and never came back.
  • What publishers fear: If a reporter needs the consent of the person being reported on, it becomes pre-censorship. The person can also withdraw consent or ask for erasure of a published report.
  • Other grounds: Government power to call for information (Section 36) may expose confidential sources. Section 44(3) has also diluted the RTI Act.
  • Court so far: The Supreme Court issued notice to the Centre on 27 October 2026 but did not stay the law. It asked the petitioners to suggest safeguards so that a journalistic exemption is not misused. 

Constitutional and legal backing of the two rights

BasisFreedom of the pressRight to privacy
Source in ConstitutionArticle 19(1)(a). Press is not named separately. Dr. Ambedkar said the press has the same right as any citizen.Article 21 (life and personal liberty), read with the freedoms in Part III.
Key judgmentsRomesh Thappar (1950): freedom of circulationBennett Coleman (1973) and Indian Express (1985): press freedom is essential to democracyRaj Narain (1975): people’s right to knowGobind v. State of M.P. (1975)R. Rajagopal (1994): right to be let alonePUCL (1997): telephone tappingK.S. Puttaswamy (2017): nine-judge bench, privacy is a Fundamental Right
LimitsOnly the eight grounds in Article 19(2): Privacy is NOT a listed ground.Puttaswamy test: there must be a law, a legitimate aim, and proportionality, with safeguards against abuse.
Statutory supportRTI Act, 2005; Press Council Act, 1978; Whistle Blowers Protection Act, 2014DPDP Act, 2023; IT Act, 2000 (Sections 43A, 72); BNS Section 72 and JJ Act Section 74 (identity of victims and children)
  • Kaushal Kishor (2023): rights under Articles 19 and 21 can be enforced even against non-State actors. So a citizen can claim privacy against a media house, not just against the State.

Where the two rights clash

The press works by collecting and publishing information about people. Privacy is about a person controlling information about herself. So friction is natural. The main flashpoints are:

FlashpointPress freedom saysPrivacy says
Consent before reportingNo corrupt official will consent to an expose. Consent rule is prior restraint.A person must control how her data is collected and used.
Erasure / right to be forgottenArchives are public record. Deleting reports rewrites history.A person should not be haunted forever by old or irrelevant reports, e.g. after acquittal.
Confidential sourcesWithout source protection, whistleblowers will not come forward.A person has a right to know who holds her data and from where it came.
Sting operationsExposes hidden wrongdoing (R.K. Anand, 2009).Secret recording is intrusion and can become entrapment. No blanket immunity (Rajat Prasad, 2014).
Media trialOpen justice; people must know what happens in courts.Reputation and fair trial of the accused are part of Article 21 (Manu Sharma, 2010; Sahara, 2012).
Private life of public figuresPublic persons are accountable to the public.Holding office does not open every part of private life to scrutiny (Rajagopal, 1994).
Information on officials under RTIAssets, qualifications, service records help check corruption.These are personal information of the employee.

How courts have handled the conflict

  • R. Rajagopal v. State of Tamil Nadu (1994), ‘Auto Shankar case’: A person has a right to be let alone. But a public official cannot claim privacy for acts done in official capacity. Material based on public records can be published. State cannot impose prior restraint on privacy grounds.
  • Sahara India Real Estate v. SEBI (2012): Courts can pass temporary postponement orders on reporting if there is real and substantial risk to fair trial.
  • Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2010): Media should not convict the accused in the court of public opinion before the verdict.
  • R.K. Anand (2009) and Rajat Prasad (2014): A sting can serve public interest, but public interest alone does not wipe out criminal liability for unlawful acts done during the sting.
  • CPIO, Supreme Court v. Subhash Chandra Agarwal (2019): Transparency and privacy have to be balanced case by case using the public interest test. Neither wins automatically.
  • Puttaswamy (2017), Justice Kaul: Right to be forgotten cannot be used where the information is needed for freedom of expression or public interest.

Why the two rights are not really opposed

  • Same root: Both come from individual liberty and dignity. After Maneka Gandhi (1978), Articles 14, 19 and 21 are read together as one ‘golden triangle’, not as separate boxes.
  • Privacy makes free speech possible: Puttaswamy held that privacy is a precondition for enjoying other freedoms. A person who is watched all the time does not think, read or speak freely.
  • The press itself needs privacy: In the Pegasus case (Manohar Lal Sharma, 2021), the Court said surveillance has a chilling effect on the press and that protection of sources is a basic condition of press freedom. So a strong privacy right protects journalists and whistleblowers.
  • Same target: Both rights are checks on power. Privacy stops the State and big companies from knowing too much about the citizen. Press freedom stops the powerful from hiding too much from the citizen.
  • Narrow area of real conflict: The clash arises only when private facts with no public relevance are published. The test is the difference between ‘public interest’ and ‘what interests the public’. An MLA’s undeclared assets fall in the first. His family’s medical records fall in the second.
  • No hierarchy of Fundamental Rights: Courts do not rank one over the other. They balance. Voters’ right to know a candidate’s assets and criminal record was upheld over the candidate’s privacy (ADR, 2002). In the Electoral Bonds case (2024), the Court used the ‘double proportionality’ test to balance the right to information against donor privacy.
  • So the real problem in the DPDP Act is not privacy itself. It is a law that applies one consent-based model to everyone and leaves no room for public interest.

How can they be balanced?

  • Narrow journalistic exemption with a code: The Justice B.N. Srikrishna Committee (2018) suggested exempting journalism from most obligations if the journalist follows a code of ethics of the Press Council or a self-regulatory body. This answers the Court’s worry about misuse.
  • Public interest test in the law: Consent, erasure and access rights should not apply where publication is in public interest. Data security duties can still apply to media houses.
  • Double proportionality: When two Fundamental Rights collide, check whether each restriction is the least intrusive way to protect the other right.
  • Restore balance in RTI: Bring back the public activity and larger public interest tests in Section 8(1)(j).
  • Protect sources by statute: The Law Commission’s 93rd Report (1983) recommended legal protection for journalists’ sources. Any demand for information under Section 36 should have judicial oversight.
  • Media self-restraint: Follow Press Council norms and NBDSA guidelines. No media trials, no naming of victims of sexual offences or children, no stings for sensation.
  • Independent regulator: The Data Protection Board is appointed by the Centre. Its independence matters when it decides complaints against the press.

How other countries do it

Country / instrumentApproach
European UnionGDPR Article 85 asks member states to reconcile data protection with journalistic expression. ECHR protects both privacy (Art. 8) and expression (Art. 10).
United KingdomData Protection Act, 2018 gives exemption if the journalist reasonably believes publication is in public interest.
United StatesFirst Amendment protects the press. Privacy Protection Act, 1980 limits search and seizure of journalists’ unpublished material.
Brazil and KenyaBrazil’s data law excludes processing for journalistic purposes. Kenya’s 2019 Act (Section 52) gives a conditional exemption.

Conclusion

Privacy and press freedom are two sides of the same democratic promise: the citizen should be protected from power, and power should be visible to the citizen. A data protection law that carves out space for honest, accountable journalism will strengthen both.

Practice MCQ

Q1. Consider the following statements:

1. Freedom of the press is expressly mentioned in Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India.

2. Right to privacy is one of the grounds listed in Article 19(2) on which freedom of speech can be restricted.

3. In K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017), the Supreme Court held privacy to be an intrinsic part of Article 21 and the freedoms guaranteed by Part III.

How many of the statements given above are correct?

(a) Only one

(b) Only two

(c) All three

(d) None

Answer: (a). Only statement 3 is correct. Press freedom is implied in Article 19(1)(a), not expressly mentioned. Privacy is not among the eight grounds in Article 19(2).

Mains Practice Question

“The right to privacy and the freedom of the press appear to pull in opposite directions, yet both serve the same constitutional goal.” Examine in the context of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023. How can the two rights be harmonised? (15 Marks, 250 words)

Tell Google you want more of this.

Add Anantam IAS as a preferred source

One tap, and this site shows up more often in your own Top Stories, AI Overviews and AI Mode. Remove it any time.

Share this

PDF

Shakshi

Written by

Shakshi

Editor — UPSC Content · Anantam IAS

Shakshi is an editor on the Anantam IAS content desk, working across study notes, Prelims revision sets and current-affairs monthly compilations for UPSC aspirants.

Specialises in · UPSC syllabus content, editing and publishing Experience · 2+ years

Want tomorrow's brief in your inbox before coffee?

We edit — we don't scrape. Every morning, one lean briefing written for UPSC Prelims + Mains relevance.