Opens in a new tab
Join Anantam IAS Channel on Telegram

The Sachar report awaits its due

Why in news?

The Sachar Committee report on Muslims completes twenty years on 17 November 2026; several key recommendations remain unimplemented.

UPSC Relevance

Prelims: Articles 29 and 30; National Commission for Minorities; notified minorities; Sachar Committee; PMJVK; PM VIKAS

Mains, GS1: Salient features of Indian society, diversity of India; communalism, regionalism and secularism

GS2: Welfare schemes for vulnerable sections; mechanisms, laws, institutions and bodies for their protection and betterment

Who is a minority in India?

  • The Constitution uses the word ‘minority’ in Articles 29, 30, 350A and 350B but does not define it.
  • It recognises two types: religious and linguistic minorities.
  • Statutory definition: Section 2(c) of the National Commission for Minorities Act, 1992 says a minority is a community notified by the Central Government.
  • Six notified communities: Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, Buddhists and Parsis (1993) and Jains (2014).
  • Census 2011: Muslims 14.2%, Christians 2.3%, Sikhs 1.7%, Buddhists 0.7%, Jains 0.4%, Parsis about 57,000. Together they are about 19% of the population.
  • T.M.A. Pai Foundation case (2002): the Supreme Court held that the unit for deciding who is a religious or linguistic minority is the State, not the whole country.
  • This has led to a demand for state-wise identification, since Hindus are fewer in number in places like Punjab, Mizoram, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Lakshadweep and Jammu and Kashmir. The matter is before the Supreme Court.
  • AMU case (2024): a seven-judge bench overruled Azeez Basha (1967). It held that an institution does not lose its minority character only because it was incorporated by a statute. What matters is who established it.

Constitutional safeguards

ArticleWhat it provides
14, 15, 16Equality before law; no discrimination on grounds of religion; equal opportunity in public employment
25 to 28Freedom of conscience and religion; freedom to manage religious affairs
29Right of any section of citizens to conserve its distinct language, script or culture
30Right of religious and linguistic minorities to establish and administer educational institutions
350AInstruction in mother tongue at primary stage for children of linguistic minorities
350BSpecial Officer for Linguistic Minorities, appointed by the President

The Sachar Committee (2005-06)

  • What it was: the Prime Minister’s High Level Committee, set up in March 2005 with seven members under Justice (Retd.) Rajinder Sachar.
  • Mandate: to study the social, economic and educational status of the Muslim community.
  • Report submitted on 17 November 2006 and tabled in Parliament on 30 November 2006.
  • It looked at the problem through three lenses: identity, security and equity.
  • It also compared Muslims with SCs, STs, Hindu OBCs, Hindu upper castes and other minorities. So it is a rare database on all social groups.

Key findings

AreaWhat the Committee found
EducationLiteracy 59.1% against a national average of about 65% (2001). One in four Muslim children aged 6 to 14 had never been to school or had dropped out. Only about 4% of Muslim children studied in madrasas.
Government jobsShare of Muslims: IAS 3%, IFS 1.8%, IPS 4%. In Railways 4.5%, and almost all of them in lower posts.
EconomyHeavy dependence on self-employment and informal work. Low share in bank credit. Urban poverty of about 38%, higher than that of SCs and STs.
InfrastructureMany Muslim-concentrated villages lacked schools, health centres, roads and bank branches.
PoliticalSeveral constituencies with a high Muslim population were reserved for SCs, which reduced their chances of representation.
Social structureMuslims are not one block. About 41% were OBCs. Arzals (former ‘untouchable’ converts) were the worst off.

Overall, the condition of Muslims was found to be slightly better than SCs and STs but below Hindu OBCs on most indicators.

Main recommendations

  • Equal Opportunity Commission (EOC) to look into complaints of discrimination from any deprived group.
  • National Data Bank with data on all socio-religious groups, and an Assessment and Monitoring Authority to review progress.
  • Diversity Index to reward institutions and employers that have a diverse mix of people.
  • Nomination procedure to increase participation of minorities in local bodies and public bodies.
  • Fair delimitation: do not reserve constituencies with a high minority population for SCs.
  • Link madrasas with school boards and recognise their degrees for higher education and competitive exams.
  • More bank branches and priority sector lending in Muslim-concentrated areas; skill training for artisans.
  • Better use of Waqf properties; sensitisation of government staff; minority members on selection boards.
  • Arzals to be treated at par with SCs or placed in a Most Backward Class category.

Steps taken so far

After the Sachar report 

  • Government accepted 72 of the 76 recommendations.
  • Prime Minister’s New 15-Point Programme (2006) for welfare of minorities.
  • Multi-sectoral Development Programme (2008) in 90 Minority Concentration Districts.
  • Pre-matric, post-matric and merit-cum-means scholarships; Maulana Azad National Fellowship (2009).
  • Expert groups on the EOC (N.R. Madhava Menon) and the Diversity Index (Amitabh Kundu). No law followed.
  • Ranganath Misra Commission (report 2007): suggested 15% reservation for minorities and delinking SC status from religion. Not accepted.
  • Kundu Committee (2014) reviewed post-Sachar progress. It found that a start had been made but the gaps remained large.
  • PMJVK (2018): restructured MsDP. Builds schools, hostels, health centres and skill centres in about 1,300 minority concentration areas.
  • PM VIKAS: merges five schemes (Seekho aur Kamao, Nai Manzil, USTTAD, Nai Roshni, Hamari Dharohar) for skilling, entrepreneurship and women’s leadership.
  • NMDFC loans; Jiyo Parsi to arrest the decline in Parsi population.
  • Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025 and the UMEED portal for registration and management of Waqf properties.
  • Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act, 2019; Haj reforms.
  • The stated approach is ‘Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas’: universal schemes like PM Awas, Ujjwala, Jan Dhan and Ayushman Bharat reach beneficiaries without looking at religion.
  • Budget 2026-27: Rs 3,400 crore for the Ministry of Minority Affairs.

Institutions: Ministry of Minority Affairs (2006), National Commission for Minorities (statutory, 1992), National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions (2004), Commissioner for Linguistic Minorities, State Minorities Commissions.

Two approaches to minority welfare

Targeted approachUniversal approach
IdeaSpecial schemes for minorities because their starting point is lowerSame schemes for all the poor; saturation coverage will reach minorities too
StrengthAddresses group-specific gaps like girls’ schooling, artisans’ creditAvoids the charge of appeasement; larger budgets; less leakage through DBT
LimitationSmall budgets; can deepen the sense of separatenessDoes not deal with discrimination or with area-specific neglect

The Sachar report itself asked for both: general policies of inclusive development along with some community-specific measures.

Challenges that remain

Political

  • The 18th Lok Sabha has 24 Muslim MPs, about 4.4% of the House, against a population share of over 14%. The highest was 49 in 1980.
  • No reserved seats, and parties give few tickets citing ‘winnability’.
  • Weak watchdog: the NCM is only a statutory and recommendatory body. It had no chairperson or member from April 2025 until July 2026, when Harjit Singh Grewal took charge.
  • Politicisation: the debate swings between ‘appeasement’ and ‘neglect’. Development of the community gets lost in between.

Educational

  • AISHE 2021-22: Muslims were 4.87% of higher education enrolment. Enrolment had fallen from 21 lakh to 19.21 lakh between 2019-20 and 2020-21.
  • High dropout after elementary level, mainly due to poverty and early entry into work.
  • Scholarships curtailed: pre-matric scholarship limited to Classes 9 and 10 (2022); Maulana Azad National Fellowship closed for new entrants from 2022-23. The government’s view is that these overlapped with other schemes and that the focus should shift to skills and infrastructure.

Economic

  • Concentration in informal work, small trade and traditional crafts with little social security.
  • Low share in regular salaried jobs and in institutional credit. Very low work participation of Muslim women.
  • Small and under-used budgets: allocations are often cut at the Revised Estimate stage.
  • Old data: all planning still rests on Census 2011. There has been no official study after the Kundu Committee.

Social and security related

  • Communal violence, hate speech and incidents of mob lynching create insecurity. The Supreme Court laid down preventive guidelines in Tehseen Poonawalla (2018) and against arbitrary demolitions in 2024.
  • Difficulty in renting or buying houses in mixed localities leads to ghettoisation.
  • Attacks on places of worship and disputes over conversion are concerns raised by Christian groups.
  • Scheme-based, not rights-based: there is no general anti-discrimination law for jobs, housing or education.

Within minorities

  • Minorities are not uniform. Jains and Parsis are better off; Pasmanda Muslims, Dalit Christians and neo-Buddhists are among the poorest.
  • Dalit Muslims and Dalit Christians do not get SC status under the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950.
  • Parsis face a demographic decline, not poverty. So one policy cannot fit all.

Way forward

  • Revisit the Sachar report in Parliament and commission a fresh status study of all socio-religious groups.
  • Set up an Equal Opportunity Commission by law. It should cover caste, religion, gender and disability together.
  • Build the National Data Bank using the coming Census, and publish group-wise data on education, jobs and credit.
  • Introduce a Diversity Index for universities, public bodies and large employers, linked with incentives.
  • Strengthen the NCM: time-bound appointments, a transparent selection panel and constitutional status on the lines of the NCSC and NCBC.
  • Keep children in school: restore scholarship support till Class 12, more girls’ hostels, and link madrasas with NIOS and state boards.
  • Livelihoods: connect artisans with PM Vishwakarma, MUDRA and e-commerce platforms; special focus on women’s work participation.
  • Target by deprivation: focus on the poorest groups within minorities such as Pasmandas and Dalit converts.
  • Security and trust: strict action on hate speech and mob violence, a more representative police force, and mixed housing.
  • Political voice: parties should give fair tickets; the nomination route suggested by Sachar can be tried in local bodies.

The Sachar report was never about one community alone. Its lasting message is that development should be measured group by group, so that no section is left behind. That fits well with the constitutional promise of equality and with the idea of Sabka Vikas.

Practice MCQs

Q1. With reference to minorities in India, consider the following statements:

1. Article 30 of the Constitution defines the term ‘minority’.

2. Six religious communities have been notified as minorities under the National Commission for Minorities Act, 1992.

3. In the T.M.A. Pai Foundation case, the Supreme Court held that the State is the unit for determining both religious and linguistic minorities.

How many of the statements given above are correct?

(a) Only one

(b) Only two

(c) All three

(d) None

Answer: (b)

Explanation: Statement 1 is incorrect. The Constitution uses the term but does not define it anywhere. Statements 2 and 3 are correct.

Q2. With reference to the Sachar Committee, consider the following statements:

1. It was a statutory commission set up under the National Commission for Minorities Act, 1992.

2. It recommended the setting up of an Equal Opportunity Commission.

3. It recommended 15% reservation for minorities in government jobs.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

(a) 1 and 2 only

(b) 2 only

(c) 2 and 3 only

(d) 1, 2 and 3

Answer: (b)

Explanation: It was the Prime Minister’s High Level Committee, not a statutory body. The 15% reservation was suggested by the Ranganath Misra Commission.

Mains Practice Question

Twenty years after the Sachar Committee report, development deficits among minorities continue. Discuss the challenges faced by minorities in India and examine the limitations of the present approach to their welfare. Suggest a way forward. (15 marks, 250 words)

Tell Google you want more of this.

Add Anantam IAS as a preferred source

One tap, and this site shows up more often in your own Top Stories, AI Overviews and AI Mode. Remove it any time.

Share this

PDF

Shakshi

Written by

Shakshi

Editor — UPSC Content · Anantam IAS

Shakshi is an editor on the Anantam IAS content desk, working across study notes, Prelims revision sets and current-affairs monthly compilations for UPSC aspirants.

Specialises in · UPSC syllabus content, editing and publishing Experience · 2+ years

Want tomorrow's brief in your inbox before coffee?

We edit — we don't scrape. Every morning, one lean briefing written for UPSC Prelims + Mains relevance.