Opens in a new tab
Join Anantam IAS Channel on Telegram

To strengthen the Supreme Court, divide it

Why in news?

Experts propose splitting the Supreme Court into a Constitutional Court and regional Courts of Appeal as pendency nears 93,000 cases.

UPSC Relevance  

Prelims: Articles 124, 130, 136, 141, 145(3); Special Leave Petition; Law Commission reports; Supreme Court judge strength.

Mains GS-2: Structure, organisation and functioning of the Judiciary; Comparison of the Indian constitutional scheme with other countries; Separation of powers.

Court of Cassation and Court of Appeal

  • Court of Cassation: A court that decides only questions of law. It does not re-examine facts. It ‘quashes’ (cassation comes from French casser – to break) wrong decisions of lower courts and settles the correct legal position. France and Italy follow this model.
  • Court of Appeal: An intermediate court that hears ordinary appeals – civil, criminal, service, tax – and corrects errors of lower courts.
  • Proposed model for India:
  • A lean Constitutional Court of about 11 judges in Delhi – only constitutional cases and substantial questions of law.
  • Four or five regional Courts of Appeal / Cassation Benches – to hear the ordinary appeals that now flood the Supreme Court.
  • Aim: Not to reduce the judiciary’s reach, but to sort its work so that questions shaping the Republic are not in the same queue as individual disputes.

Special Leave Petition (Article 136) – the root of the problem

  • What it is: The Supreme Court may, in its discretion, grant special leave to appeal against any judgment, order or decree of any court or tribunal in India (except those under laws relating to the Armed Forces).
  • Original intent: A rare safety valve for exceptional cases of grave injustice. In Pritam Singh v. State (1950), the Court said this power must be used sparingly.
  • Reality: SLPs made up 84.6% of the Court’s admission docket in 2011. The Court has turned into a general ‘fourth court of appeal’ – trial court, first appeal, High Court, then Supreme Court.
  • Court’s own admission: In Bihar Legal Support Society (1986), a Constitution Bench under CJI P.N. Bhagwati said the Court was never meant to be an ordinary court of appeal.
  • No filter: Unlike the US, there is no strong screening mechanism. Almost every litigant who loses in a High Court tries an SLP.

Why the reform is needed

IndicatorData
Pending cases (end of 2025)92,318 – highest ever, nearly 10,000 more than a year earlier
Cases disposed in 202565,615 – but 75,410 fresh cases filed
Judge strengthRaised to 34 in 2019 (pendency then about 60,000); raised to 38 in 2026
Constitution Bench decisionsAbout 134 a year in early 1960s; fewer than 10 a year in the last decade
  • Constitutional role is shrinking: Big questions of law wait for years. In 2016, a three-judge Bench framed 11 questions on whether the Court had ‘lost its way’ and referred them to a larger Bench (V. Vasanthakumar case). That reference is still unheard a decade later.
  • Adding judges is not enough: More judges have not reduced pendency. As the article says, the task is not to move the same work faster, but to sort it.
  • Inconsistent rulings: The Court already sits in a dozen small Benches of two or three judges, which sometimes contradict each other. This weakens the binding value of its law under Article 141.
  • Access to justice: A single court in Delhi is distant and costly for litigants from the South, East and Northeast. The Law Commission noted that a larger share of appeals comes from High Courts near Delhi.
  • Specialisation: A dedicated Constitutional Court, sitting in larger Benches, could give consistent and well-reasoned rulings that settle questions once.
  • Article 145(3): Requires at least five judges for substantial questions of constitutional interpretation. Under heavy load, forming such Benches regularly is difficult.

Committee recommendations

BodyRecommendation
229th Law Commission Report (2009)Constitution Bench in Delhi and four regional Cassation Benches (North, South, East, West). Argued Article 130 may permit this without a constitutional amendment
Parliamentary Standing Committee (2023)Recommended regional Benches of the Supreme Court; Law Ministry has accepted the suggestion
V. Vasanthakumar case (2016)Proposed a National Court of Appeal; questions referred to a Constitution Bench
  • Article 130: The Supreme Court sits in Delhi or at any other place that the Chief Justice of India may decide, with the approval of the President. This is the legal hook for regional Benches.
  • National Court of Appeal vs regional Benches: A separate National Court of Appeal would likely need a constitutional amendment, while regional Benches of the same Supreme Court may be possible under Article 130.

International examples

CountryModel
USASupreme Court sits over 13 federal Courts of Appeals. Uses certiorari (discretion since 1925) – hears roughly 1% of about 7,000 petitions a year
South AfricaConstitutional Court in Johannesburg; separate Supreme Court of Appeal in Bloemfontein for other matters
Brazil1988 Constitution created a Superior Tribunal of Justice to take over appeals. A 2004 reform allowed the apex court to hear only cases of ‘general repercussion’
FranceCour de cassation for ordinary law; Conseil constitutionnel for constitutional review
  • Lesson from Brazil: The split alone did not reduce backlog. Pendency fell only after the apex court got the power to filter out cases. So India would need both – a split and a filter.

Arguments against

  • Unity of the Supreme Court: Successive Chief Justices worry that a divided court may no longer be ‘supreme’. Its authority partly comes from being the single, final word.
  • Regional courts as lesser forums: Litigants may keep pressing to reach the Constitutional Court in Delhi, adding one more layer of litigation.
  • Conflicting regional precedents: Different Cassation Benches may interpret the same law differently, needing a mechanism to resolve conflicts.
  • Not every issue fits neatly: Many ordinary appeals involve fundamental rights (e.g., personal liberty under Article 21), making separation of ‘constitutional’ and ‘ordinary’ work difficult.
  • Court’s own resistance: The Supreme Court has repeatedly declined requests for regional Benches through its own administrative decisions.
  • Counter-argument: The Court is already divided – not by design but by volume – into scattered small Benches whose rulings cannot always be reconciled. A planned split may in fact restore its constitutional core.

Way forward

  • Two-tier structure: Constitutional Court in Delhi plus regional Courts of Appeal, beginning with Benches under Article 130.
  • Filter for SLPs: Clear criteria for admission, similar to ‘general repercussion’ in Brazil or certiorari in the US, so only cases of public importance reach the top court.
  • Strengthen High Courts: Fill vacancies and improve quality of judgments so fewer appeals are needed.
  • Permanent Constitution Benches: Fixed Benches that sit through the year on constitutional matters.
  • Conflict-resolution mechanism: A larger Bench of the Constitutional Court to settle conflicting regional rulings.
  • Broad consensus: Build agreement among the judiciary, executive, Parliament and Bar before restructuring.

The Supreme Court that gave India the basic structure doctrine now rarely sits in constitutional judgment. Sorting its work – rather than just adding judges – may be the way to restore its role as a constitutional court while giving ordinary litigants faster justice.

Practice MCQ 

Q1. Consider the following statements:

1. Under Article 136, the Supreme Court can grant special leave to appeal against orders of any court or tribunal in India, except those constituted under laws relating to the Armed Forces.

2. An aggrieved party has a constitutional right to have its Special Leave Petition heard on merits.

3. Under Article 130, the Supreme Court may sit at places other than Delhi as decided by the Chief Justice of India with the approval of the President.

How many of the above statements are correct?

(a) Only one     (b) Only two     (c) All three     (d) None

Answer: (b)

Explanation: Statement 2 is incorrect. Special leave is purely discretionary; it is not a right of appeal.

Q2. Consider the following statements:

Statement-I: The 229th Law Commission Report suggested that regional Cassation Benches of the Supreme Court could be set up without a constitutional amendment.

Statement-II: The Constitution allows the Supreme Court to sit at places other than Delhi with the approval of the President.

Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above statements?

(a) Both Statement-I and Statement-II are correct and Statement-II explains Statement-I

(b) Both Statement-I and Statement-II are correct, but Statement-II does not explain Statement-I

(c) Statement-I is correct, but Statement-II is incorrect

(d) Statement-I is incorrect, but Statement-II is correct

Answer: (a)

Explanation: The Law Commission relied on Article 130, which allows the Court to sit elsewhere, to argue that regional Benches need no amendment.

Mains Practice Question 

“The Supreme Court of India has gradually turned from a constitutional court into a general court of appeal.” In this context, critically examine the proposal to create a Constitutional Court and regional Courts of Appeal. (15 marks, 250 words)

Tell Google you want more of this.

Add Anantam IAS as a preferred source

One tap, and this site shows up more often in your own Top Stories, AI Overviews and AI Mode. Remove it any time.

Share this

PDF

Shakshi

Written by

Shakshi

Editor — UPSC Content · Anantam IAS

Shakshi is an editor on the Anantam IAS content desk, working across study notes, Prelims revision sets and current-affairs monthly compilations for UPSC aspirants.

Specialises in · UPSC syllabus content, editing and publishing Experience · 2+ years

Want tomorrow's brief in your inbox before coffee?

We edit — we don't scrape. Every morning, one lean briefing written for UPSC Prelims + Mains relevance.