Critically evaluate the important factors of India-Maldives relations on the eve of sixty years of diplomatic ties between the two countries.
Subtopic: Paper II · India-Maldives relations at sixty years of diplomatic ties
How to structure your answer
Take the enduring factors first, then the disruptive ones, then the correction, and judge the structural position.
Detailed model answer
287 words · target 200 words · 12 min
India recognised the Maldives immediately after its independence in 1965 and established relations in 1965, making the relationship one of the oldest in India's neighbourhood policy.
The enduring factors.
- Security provision. Operation Cactus in 1988, when Indian forces reversed a coup attempt within hours, remains the founding act of trust and is still cited in both capitals.
- First responder. The 2004 tsunami, the 2014 Male water crisis when India airlifted drinking water, and pandemic vaccine supply.
- Development and capacity. The Greater Male Connectivity Project, housing, the Indira Gandhi Memorial Hospital, and the largest share of Maldivian training slots in Indian institutions.
- Location. The archipelago sits astride the sea lanes carrying the bulk of India's energy imports, which makes maritime domain awareness there a direct Indian interest.
The disruptive factors.
- Domestic politics. The relationship has become an electoral issue, with the India Out campaign in 2023 turning the small Indian military presence — helicopters and a Dornier aircraft for medical evacuation and surveillance — into a sovereignty question. Indian personnel were replaced by civilian technical staff in 2024.
- The China factor. The free trade agreement and infrastructure lending give Male an alternative, and debt sustainability has become a live concern.
- Asymmetry management. The chief Maldivian complaint is not Indian assistance but the perception of Indian oversight, which small states resent structurally.
The correction. Relations were repaired through economic instruments rather than political ones — currency swap support, budgetary assistance and continued infrastructure work, at a point when the Maldives faced serious external debt pressure.
Assessment. Sixty years show a relationship that is structurally close and politically volatile. India's error has been to treat proximity as entitlement; the durable lesson is that in an asymmetric relationship, visible respect for sovereignty is not a courtesy but the price of influence.
What an examiner expects to see
- Security provision. Operation Cactus in 1988, when Indian forces reversed a coup attempt within hours, remains the founding act of trust and is still cited in both capitals.
- First responder. The 2004 tsunami, the 2014 Male water crisis when India airlifted drinking water, and pandemic vaccine supply.
- Development and capacity. The Greater Male Connectivity Project, housing, the Indira Gandhi Memorial Hospital, and the largest share of Maldivian training slots in Indian institutions.
- Location. The archipelago sits astride the sea lanes carrying the bulk of India's energy imports, which makes maritime domain awareness there a direct Indian interest.
- Domestic politics. The relationship has become an electoral issue, with the India Out campaign in 2023 turning the small Indian military presence — helicopters and a Dornier aircraft for medical evacuation and surveillance — into a sovereignty question. Indian personnel were replaced by civilian technical staff in 2024.
- The China factor. The free trade agreement and infrastructure lending give Male an alternative, and debt sustainability has become a live concern.
- Asymmetry management. The chief Maldivian complaint is not Indian assistance but the perception of Indian oversight, which small states resent structurally.