Neglect of primary health care and education in India are reasons for its backwardness.
Subtopic: Economy & Development · human capital, primary health and elementary education
How to structure your answer
Written within the word limit
315 words · target 1200 words · 90 min
Interpreting the Topic
Backwardness here means human-development failure — short, unhealthy, poorly schooled lives — not merely a low GDP rank. The topic argues that India under-invested in the two foundations everything else stands on: primary health care and elementary education. The essay must marshal evidence, trace the causal chain to national backwardness, admit other causes, and point to societies that chose differently.
Dimensions to Develop
- The evidence of neglect: government health spending hovers around 2 per cent of GDP against the National Health Policy 2017 target of 2.5; education spending stays near 4.5 per cent against the 6 per cent recommended by the Kothari Commission and reiterated by NEP 2020; ASER surveys show a majority of rural Class 5 children cannot read a Class 2 text; NFHS-5 records 35.5 per cent child stunting.
- The causal chain: Amartya Sen's capability approach — an unlettered, unhealthy citizen cannot convert growth into freedom; low learning means low productivity; out-of-pocket health shocks push millions into poverty each year.
- The tertiary bias: prestige hospitals and universities absorbed resources while sub-centres and government primary schools decayed — an inverted pyramid of provision.
- The counter-view: backwardness has other parents too — colonial deindustrialisation, caste inequality, weak governance — so foundational neglect is a principal, not the sole, reason.
- Proof of the alternative: Kerala and Sri Lanka achieved first-world health indicators at modest incomes; East Asia's growth miracle was built on universal basic schooling before factories.
Quotes and Anchors
- Sen and Dreze's An Uncertain Glory — growth without social foundations stays uncertain.
- Vivekananda's idea of education as the manifestation of perfection already in man.
- Course correction underway: NIPUN Bharat for foundational literacy, Ayushman Arogya Mandirs for primary care — direction right, scale still short.
Closing Synthesis
Nations are not built in operation theatres and IITs alone; they are built in anganwadis, sub-centres and primary classrooms. India's backwardness is, at root, a postponed investment in its own people — and the returns on finally paying that arrear remain the highest available anywhere in the economy.
What an examiner expects to see
- Define backwardness in human-development terms (Sen's capability approach), not just GDP — this reframing anchors the whole essay.
- Hard evidence of neglect: about 2% of GDP public health spending vs the NHP 2017 target of 2.5%; about 4.5% on education vs the 6% Kothari/NEP 2020 benchmark; ASER learning-poverty findings; NFHS-5 stunting at 35.5%.
- Causal chain: weak foundations → low productivity and impoverishing out-of-pocket health shocks → persistent poverty; childhood losses in nutrition and learning are largely irreversible, so deficits compound.
- Tertiary-bias argument: prestige institutions absorbed resources while sub-centres and primary schools decayed — an inverted pyramid of provision.
- Balanced view: colonial extraction, inequality and governance failures are co-authors of backwardness; foundational neglect is a principal, not sole, cause.
- Positive proof: Kerala, Sri Lanka and East Asia delivered development through basic health and schooling ahead of, and then through, growth.
- Course correction: NIPUN Bharat, NEP 2020, Ayushman Arogya Mandirs — acknowledge, but note spending still lags stated targets.
Concrete cases, schemes and judgments
- ASER surveys: a majority of rural Class 5 children cannot read a Class 2-level text
- NFHS-5 (2019-21): 35.5% of children under five are stunted
- National Health Policy 2017 target of 2.5% of GDP for public health — still unmet
- Kerala and Sri Lanka: near-universal literacy and low infant mortality at modest incomes
- East Asian miracle economies invested in universal schooling before industrial take-off
- Ayushman Arogya Mandirs — upgraded primary-care centres exceeding 1.6 lakh