There are better practices to ‘best practices’.
Subtopic: Polity & Governance · context-sensitive governance beyond best practices
How to structure your answer
Written within the word limit
262 words · target 1200 words · 90 min
Interpreting the Topic
The quotation marks around 'best practices' are the essay's key: it questions the managerial cult of the single proven template. 'Best' freezes yesterday's solution as today's ceiling and ignores context; 'better' is a direction — iterative, local, always improvable. The essay must argue that governance and development advance through continuous, context-sensitive learning rather than imported perfection.
Dimensions to Develop
- The seduction of best practice: benchmarking promises certainty and borrowed legitimacy — but institutions can mimic the form of success without its function, what development scholars call isomorphic mimicry.
- Transplant failures: education, sanitation and policing templates copied across contexts underperform because geography, administrative capacity and culture differ; the same uniform fits no one.
- Better practice as process: kaizen-style continuous improvement, pilots before scale, problem-driven iteration — measure, adapt, repeat; evaluation over imitation.
- Indian evidence of leapfrogging: UPI bypassed the card-based 'best practice' of the West to build a superior public payments rail; Aadhaar-enabled DBT, Kudumbashree's SHG architecture and mohalla clinics are home-grown betters now studied globally.
- Institutionalising learning: the Aspirational Districts Programme replaced templates with ranked, district-specific improvement; states as laboratories of federalism generate a portfolio of experiments rather than one national orthodoxy.
Quotes and Anchors
- Voltaire: 'The best is the enemy of the good.'
- Deming's discipline: decide on data, improve without end.
Closing Synthesis
Conclude that excellence is a verb, not a certificate. The question that matures governance is not 'what is the best practice elsewhere?' but 'what works here, and how do we make it work better next year?' Societies that institutionalise that question out-learn — and therefore out-govern — societies that laminate their answers.
What an examiner expects to see
- Read the quotation marks: the essay interrogates the managerial cult of 'best practices' — templates that freeze yesterday's solution as today's ceiling.
- Name the failure mode: isomorphic mimicry — adopting the form of successful institutions without their function.
- Argue context over template: transplanted models underperform because capacity, geography and culture differ.
- Define 'better practices' as a process: iterate, measure, adapt — kaizen and problem-driven learning over imitation.
- Prove with Indian leapfrogs: UPI surpassing card-based models; Aadhaar-DBT; Kudumbashree; the Aspirational Districts Programme's ranked, district-specific improvement.
- Close on federalism as a portfolio of experiments: states as laboratories generating betters, not enforcing one best.
Concrete cases, schemes and judgments
- UPI leapfrogging the card-network 'best practice' to become a globally studied public payments rail
- Aspirational Districts Programme — district-specific improvement deltas over national templates
- Kudumbashree's home-grown SHG architecture in Kerala
- Lant Pritchett and co-authors' critique of isomorphic mimicry in development
- Delhi mohalla clinics adapting primary care to urban density