UPSC CSE 2026 Essay Paper Discussion
GS Paper 2 15 marks · 250w 14 min Hard

US secondary tariffs raised duties on Indian goods to 50 percent in August 2025 over Russian-oil purchases before the 6 February 2026 framework rolled them back to 18 percent. Examine how this episode tested India’s strategic autonomy.

Subtopic: IR · Effect of policies of developed/developing countries on India

Model answer outline

How to structure your answer

Introduction: India's strategic autonomy was stress-tested when the US imposed a 25 percent reciprocal tariff plus a 25 percent penalty on Indian goods in August 2025, tied to a July 2025 executive order monitoring Russian-oil buyers.

Body: Three dimensions — (i) Pressure metrics: India-US goods trade $129.2 billion (2024); US trade deficit with India $45.7 billion; tariffs landed because the US is India's largest goods export market at 18 percent of exports; (ii) Indian counterplay: Russian crude share rose from 2 percent (2021) to 35.9 percent (FY24); after Rosneft-Lukoil sanctions (21 November 2025), share fell to 21.2 percent by January 2026; (iii) 6 February 2026 framework rolled tariffs back to 18 percent without India officially conceding on Russian oil; Jaishankar reiterated strategic autonomy at Munich 14 February 2026.

Way forward / Conclusion: Diversify oil basket beyond Russia (now from 40 countries), conclude India-US trade pact, push rupee internationalisation rather than de-dollarisation, and harden CAATSA waiver clarity through legislation.

Full model answer

Written within the word limit

212 words · target 250 words · 14 min

Introduction:

India's strategic autonomy was stress-tested when the United States imposed a 25 percent reciprocal tariff plus a 25 percent penalty on Indian goods in August 2025 — taking duties to 50 percent — tied to a July 2025 executive order monitoring Russian-oil buyers. The 6 February 2026 framework rolled tariffs back to 18 percent without an official Indian concession on Russian crude.

Pressure metrics: India-US goods trade reached $129.2 billion in 2024 with a US deficit of $45.7 billion; tariffs hurt because the United States is India's largest goods export market at 18 percent of exports. Engineering goods, gems and jewellery and pharma — high-employment sectors — bore the brunt.

Indian counterplay: Russian crude share rose from 2 percent (2021) to 35.9 percent (FY24); after Rosneft and Lukoil sanctions (21 November 2025), it fell to 21.2 percent by January 2026. India diversified imports from 40 countries, signed the India-EU FTA (27 January 2026), accelerated UPI internationalisation and used the Munich Security Conference (14 February 2026) to restate strategic autonomy — Jaishankar invoked Article 51's non-alignment lineage.

Framework rollback: The 6 February 2026 framework recovered baseline access without scripting Indian alignment, vindicating non-aligned multi-alignment over coercion-driven choices. CAATSA waiver clarity, however, remains legislatively absent.

Way forward / Conclusion:

Diversify the oil basket beyond Russia, conclude the bilateral trade pact with sequenced market access, push rupee internationalisation rather than de-dollarisation, and harden CAATSA waiver clarity through US legislation — converting the episode's lesson into durable policy.

Key points

What an examiner expects to see

  • August 2025 — US tariffs raised to 50 percent on Indian goods (25% reciprocal + 25% penalty)
  • Tariff penalty tied to July 2025 US Executive Order on Russian-oil buyers
  • Russian oil share — under 1 percent (2021) to 35.9 percent (FY24); fell to 21.2 percent (January 2026)
  • 21 November 2025 — US sanctioned Rosneft and Lukoil
  • 6 February 2026 — US-India Trade Framework reduced tariffs to 18 percent
  • US-India goods trade $129.2 billion (2024); US deficit $45.7 billion
  • Jaishankar at Munich (14 February 2026) — India 'wedded to strategic autonomy'
  • CAATSA 2017 secondary-sanctions risk on Russian defence and energy
Examples to use

Concrete cases, schemes and judgments

  • US-India Trade Framework (6 February 2026)
  • US Executive Order on Russian-oil buyers (July 2025)
  • Sanctions on Rosneft and Lukoil (21 November 2025)
  • Munich Security Conference (14 February 2026)
  • S-400 system deliveries delayed by Russia-Ukraine war
Keywords / terms

Terminology to weave into the answer

strategic autonomysecondary sanctionsCAATSARussian oilUS tariffsmultialignmentMunichRosneft
Sources to read

Primary sources and verified references

White House — US-India Trade Framework (February 2026) https://www.whitehouse.gov/fact-sheets/2026/02/fact-sheet-the-united-states-and-india-announce-historic-trade-deal/ USTR — India trade summary https://ustr.gov/countries-regions/south-central-asia/india Russian Revolution 1917 — Anantam IAS https://anantamias.com/russian-revolution-1917/

Share this answer