GS Paper 3 15 marks · 250w 14 min Medium
With growing energy needs should India keep on expanding its nuclear energy programme? Discuss the facts and fears associated with nuclear energy.
Subtopic: Science and Technology
How to structure your answer
Introduction → Facts Supporting Nuclear Expansion → Associated Fears and Challenges → Conclusion
Detailed model answer
436 words · target 250 words · 14 min
India's current installed nuclear capacity is approximately 8.78 GW, contributing about 3% to the country's total electricity generation. India has set an ambitious target to achieve 100 GW of nuclear power capacity by 2047.
Facts Supporting Nuclear Expansion:
- Energy Security: Nuclear power drastically reduces reliance on imported fossil fuels and insulates the economy from global supply chain disruptions.
- Reliable Baseload Power: Unlike solar and wind, which are intermittent, a nuclear plant provides continuous 24/7 power, making it an essential grid stabiliser.
- Supports renewable integration: Nuclear energy can complement solar and wind by providing stable power when renewable generation is low.
- Economic Multiplier: Once constructed, nuclear plants have long lifespans (40-60 years) with very low marginal generation costs.
- Technological self-reliance: India's 3-stage nuclear program is designed to eventually leverage its vast Thorium reserves, which would provide centuries of domestic energy sovereignty.
- Land-efficient: Nuclear plants require far less land per unit of electricity generated compared to large solar or wind parks.
- Reduced air pollution: Replacing coal-based power with nuclear energy can reduce particulate pollution, SOx, NOx and associated public-health costs.
- Decarbonising hard-to-abate sectors: Nuclear energy can provide process heat and clean power for steel, aluminium, chemicals, fertilisers and hydrogen production.
- Climate Commitments: Nuclear energy produces zero greenhouse gases during operation, which is vital for India meeting its Net Zero by 2070 target and fulfilling COP28 pledges.
- Wider developmental benefits: Nuclear research supports cancer treatment, radioisotopes, food irradiation, crop improvement, water desalination and scientific research.
Associated Fears and Challenges:
- Safety risks: Memories of disasters like Chornobyl and Fukushima drive public apprehension about radiation exposure and major accidents.
- High capital costs: Nuclear projects require massive upfront investments (₹12-15 crore per MW) and long gestation periods (10-15 years), which often lead to cost overruns.
- Uranium supply dependence: Nuclear power reduces fossil-fuel imports, but India still depends partly on imported uranium until the thorium cycle matures.
- Radioactive waste: Spent nuclear fuel remains hazardous for thousands of years, and the lack of permanent deep geological repositories remains a major environmental challenge.
- Water scarcity: Nuclear reactors require massive amounts of water for cooling, which strains local water resources in drought-prone or heavily agricultural regions.
- Climate risks to nuclear plants: Coastal plants face risks from cyclones, sea-level rise, flooding and thermal stress.
- Strategic and security risks: Nuclear facilities need strong protection against cyberattacks, sabotage, terrorism and proliferation-related concerns.
- Public opposition: Land acquisition and local displacement fears often lead to protests and delays.
Expanding nuclear energy is critical for India's energy security and net-zero commitments. Anchored by policy reforms like the SHANTI Act, Nuclear power is a reliable, zero-emission baseload alternative to coal that can support India’s rapidly growing $5-trillion economy.
What an examiner expects to see
- Energy Security: Nuclear power drastically reduces reliance on imported fossil fuels and insulates the economy from global supply chain disruptions
- Reliable Baseload Power: Unlike solar and wind, which are intermittent, a nuclear plant provides continuous 24/7 power, making it an essential grid
- Supports renewable integration: Nuclear energy can complement solar and wind by providing stable power when renewable generation is low
- Economic Multiplier: Once constructed, nuclear plants have long lifespans (40-60 years) with very low marginal generation costs
- Technological self-reliance: India's 3-stage nuclear program is designed to eventually leverage its vast Thorium reserves, which would provide centuries
- Land-efficient: Nuclear plants require far less land per unit of electricity generated compared to large solar or wind parks
- Reduced air pollution: Replacing coal-based power with nuclear energy can reduce particulate pollution, SOx, NOx and associated public-health costs
Terminology to weave into the answer
SHANTI ActFacts Supporting Nuclear ExpansionEnergy SecurityReliable Baseload PowerEconomic MultiplierClimate Commitments