Why in news?
World Bank’s latest brief shows India’s extreme poverty at 2.6%, renewing debate as India lacks an updated official poverty line.
UPSC Relevance
Prelims – Poverty line committees, National MPI, HCES, World Bank poverty lines
Mains, GS1 – Poverty and developmental issues
GS2 – Issues relating to poverty and hunger; welfare schemes for vulnerable sections
GS3 – Inclusive growth and issues arising from it
No Consensus on Poverty Numbers
- Everyone agrees poverty has fallen sharply in the last decade in India. Nobody agrees on how many Indians are still poor.
- For the same year, 2022-23, estimates range from about 3% to more than 26%. The country and the year are the same. Only the yardstick changes.
| Source | Yardstick | Poverty |
|---|---|---|
| World Bank | $3 a day | 2.6% |
| SBI Research (2025) | Tendulkar line adjusted for inflation: ₹1,632 rural, ₹1,944 urban | 7.2% rural, 4.6% urban |
| Rangarajan and Dev | Rangarajan line adjusted for inflation | 10.8% |
| NITI Aayog | National MPI (projection) | 11.28% |
| World Bank | $4.20 a day | 16.1% |
- The last official poverty estimate is for 2011-12 (Tendulkar method). Since then India has had no officially accepted poverty line.
What is poverty and how is it defined?
- Poverty is a condition where a person cannot meet the minimum needs of life such as food, clothing, shelter, health and education.
- Absolute poverty: living below a fixed minimum level of consumption or income. India has always used this approach.
- Relative poverty: being poor in comparison to others in society, e.g. earning less than half the median income. Used mostly in developed countries.
- Poverty line: the cut-off level of monthly per capita consumption expenditure (MPCE). Anyone below it is counted as poor.
- Why consumption and not income? Most Indians work in the informal sector, incomes are irregular and under-reported. Consumption is more stable and easier to record.
- Common measures:
- Head Count Ratio (HCR): share of population below the poverty line. Most widely used.
- Poverty Gap: how far below the line the poor are on average. Shows the depth of poverty.
- Squared Poverty Gap: gives more weight to the poorest. Shows severity.
How has India measured poverty? The journey
| Effort | Year | Key features |
|---|---|---|
| Dadabhai Naoroji | Pre-1947 | First estimate, in ‘Poverty and Un-British Rule in India’. Based on cost of a subsistence (jail) diet. Line of ₹16 to ₹35 per person per year. |
| Planning Commission Working Group | 1962 | ₹20 (rural) and ₹25 (urban) per person per month. Left out health and education as the State was expected to provide them. |
| Dandekar and Rath | 1971 | First systematic study using NSS data. Based on 2,250 calories per day. |
| Y.K. Alagh Task Force | 1979 | Separate calorie norms: 2,400 kcal rural and 2,100 kcal urban. Poverty line was the spending needed to buy this food basket. |
| Lakdawala Expert Group | 1993 | Kept the calorie norm. Introduced State-specific poverty lines. Used CPI-AL (rural) and CPI-IW (urban) for price updates. |
| Tendulkar Committee | 2009 | Dropped the direct calorie method. Wider basket including private spending on health and education. Same basket for rural and urban. Poverty at 21.9% in 2011-12. |
| Rangarajan Committee | 2014 | Higher lines. Brought back separate rural and urban baskets with calorie, protein and fat norms. Poverty at 29.5% in 2011-12. Not officially accepted. |
| NITI Aayog Task Force (Arvind Panagariya) | 2015-16 | Did not fix a line. Suggested a new expert group to decide. No action since. |
Data source: Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES)
- Conducted by the National Statistics Office under MoSPI. Earlier done every five years.
- The 2017-18 survey was never published, citing data quality issues. The next full survey came only in 2022-23, followed by 2023-24.
- HCES 2023-24: average MPCE of ₹4,122 (rural) and ₹6,996 (urban). Rural-urban gap fell from about 84% in 2011-12 to about 70%.
- The new surveys use a changed method (multiple visits, more items, value of free items shown separately). So comparing them with 2011-12 is not straightforward.
Beyond consumption: Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI)
- National MPI is brought out by NITI Aayog with UNDP and OPHI, using National Family Health Survey (NFHS) data. It follows the Alkire-Foster method.
- 3 dimensions with equal weight, 12 indicators:
- Health: nutrition, child and adolescent mortality, maternal health
- Education: years of schooling, school attendance
- Standard of living: cooking fuel, sanitation, drinking water, electricity, housing, assets, bank account
- Maternal health and bank account are India’s additions. The global MPI has 10 indicators.
- A household is multidimensionally poor if it is deprived in one-third or more of the weighted indicators.
- Multidimensional poverty fell from 24.85% (2015-16) to 14.96% (2019-21). The 11.28% figure for 2022-23 is a projection, not a survey result.
World Bank’s international poverty lines
- Revised in June 2025 to 2021 PPP prices: $3 a day (extreme poverty, earlier $2.15), $4.20 (lower-middle-income countries) and $8.30 (upper-middle-income countries).
- Useful for comparing countries. But they are not built on what it costs to meet basic needs in India.
- About 80% of Indians lived below the $8.30 line in 2023, and about 30% still lack basic sanitation.
Problems and challenges in measuring poverty
- No official line: The Tendulkar line is over 15 years old. Rangarajan was never accepted. Policy debate has no agreed anchor.
- Line is too low: ₹27 to ₹33 a day was criticised as a ‘starvation line’. It tells us who survives, not who lives decently.
- Data gaps: No published consumption data between 2011-12 and 2022-23. Census after 2011 was delayed, so sampling frames and beneficiary lists are old.
- Comparability: Change in survey method and recall period means old and new numbers cannot be compared directly.
- Method dispute: One group updates an old line for inflation. The other rebuilds the basket from present spending patterns. Results differ widely.
- Outdated basket: Spending has shifted from food to non-food items like rent, transport, mobile data, private schooling and health care. Old baskets do not reflect this.
- Survey vs national accounts: Consumption captured in surveys is far lower than in National Accounts. Richer households are under-covered.
- Free goods: Should free foodgrain and other transfers be counted as consumption? Counting them lowers poverty but hides dependence on welfare.
- Limits of MPI: It measures access, not quality (school attendance, not learning). It is based on NFHS, which comes at long gaps. It complements a poverty line but cannot replace it.
- Vulnerability ignored: Many households are just above the line. One illness, crop failure or job loss pushes them back.
- Estimation vs identification: Counting the poor (HCES) and identifying them for schemes (SECC 2011, NFSA lists based on Census 2011) are separate and both are outdated.
- Regional and urban cost differences: One national number hides wide gaps between States and the high cost of living in cities.
- Politicisation: Poverty numbers are tied to government performance and to entitlements, so every revision becomes controversial.
Why a proper measure matters for Viksit Bharat 2047
- A higher bar: A country aiming at high-income status cannot judge itself by a $3 line. If 80% are below the upper-middle-income line, the distance to 2047 is clear only with honest measurement.
- Better targeting: Welfare spending on food, housing, health cover and cash transfers runs into lakhs of crores. A credible benchmark reduces inclusion and exclusion errors.
- Evaluating schemes: Without a baseline, we cannot say which programmes actually reduced poverty.
- Fiscal federalism: Finance Commission transfers and central scheme allocations depend on reliable State-level poverty and income data.
- SDG commitment: SDG target 1.2 asks countries to halve poverty ‘according to national definitions’ by 2030. That needs a national definition.
- Inclusive growth: Low extreme poverty can hide inequality and insecurity. A developed India needs a large, secure middle class, not people hovering just above the line.
- Human capital: The demographic dividend pays only if deprivation in nutrition, health and learning is tracked and removed.
- Credibility: Agreed numbers improve public debate and investor and global confidence in Indian statistics.
Way forward
- Set up a new expert group to fix an official poverty line using HCES 2022-23 and 2023-24 data.
- Use more than one line: an extreme poverty line, plus a higher ‘decent living’ or vulnerability line suited to a lower-middle-income country. Track relative poverty too.
- Use consumption line and MPI together. One shows purchasing power, the other shows access to services.
- Modern basket: include housing rent, transport, communication, education and health at actual cost. Revise the basket every five years and keep State-wise, rural and urban lines.
- Regular and timely data: fixed calendar for HCES, release of unit-level data, and a stronger, independent National Statistical Commission.
- Measure income also: take forward MoSPI’s planned household income survey and use tax, GST and other administrative data to capture the top end.
- Update beneficiary lists: use the coming Census to revise NFSA coverage and build a dynamic social registry in place of SECC 2011.
- Add quality to MPI: learning outcomes, nutrition quality, and functional (not just built) toilets and taps.
- De-link basic entitlements from a single line: health, education and nutrition should be near universal, so that a measurement error does not exclude the needy.
Conclusion
India’s progress against poverty is real. But without a credible, updated benchmark it is hard to say how much has been achieved and how much is left. A developed India by 2047 has to be measured not by how few people starve, but by how many can live decently.
Practice MCQ
Q1. With reference to poverty estimation in India, consider the following statements:
1. The Lakdawala Expert Group introduced State-specific poverty lines.
2. The Tendulkar Committee retained the calorie norm as the direct basis of the poverty line.
3. The poverty line recommended by the Rangarajan Committee is the current official poverty line of India.
How many of the statements given above are correct?
(a) Only one
(b) Only two
(c) All three
(d) None
Answer: (a). Only statement 1 is correct. Tendulkar moved away from the calorie norm. The Rangarajan report was never officially accepted.
Q2. With reference to the National Multidimensional Poverty Index, consider the following statements:
1. It is released by NITI Aayog and uses National Family Health Survey data.
2. It includes maternal health and bank account as indicators, which are not part of the global MPI.
3. A household is counted as multidimensionally poor only if it is deprived in at least half of the weighted indicators.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only
(b) 2 and 3 only
(c) 1 and 3 only
(d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer: (a). Statement 3 is wrong. The cut-off is one-third (33%) of the weighted indicators, not half.
Mains Practice Question
“India has reduced poverty sharply, yet it cannot say with confidence how many of its people are poor.” Discuss the problems in the way poverty is measured in India. Why is a credible poverty benchmark important for the goal of Viksit Bharat 2047? (15 Marks, 250 words)
Tell Google you want more of this.
Add Anantam IAS as a preferred sourceOne tap, and this site shows up more often in your own Top Stories, AI Overviews and AI Mode. Remove it any time.