Why in news?
The Indian Police Foundation has finalised a “change manual” for internal police reforms, to be first implemented in Punjab.
UPSC Relevance
Prelims – Police as a State subject
Mains, GS2, Government Policies and Interventions; Transparency and Accountability; Role of Civil Services in a Democracy
Police in the Constitution
- “Police” and “Public order” are State subjects (Entries 2 and 1 of List II, Seventh Schedule). States make police laws, but many still follow the colonial Police Act, 1861 or laws modelled on it.
- The Union assists States through the scheme for Modernisation of State Police Forces, CCTNS (Crime and Criminal Tracking Network and Systems) and central training institutions like BPR&D.
Why are Police Reforms Needed?
- Colonial mindset: The 1861 Act was designed to control people, not serve them. This “ruler’s police” image still keeps citizens away from police stations.
- Shortage of personnel: As per Bureau of Police Research and Development (BPR&D)’s Data on Police Organisations (1 January 2020), over 5.31 lakh posts were vacant against a sanctioned strength of about 26.2 lakh. The actual police-population ratio (around 158 per lakh in 2019) is well below the sanctioned level.
- Low share of women: Women formed only about 10% of the police force (2020), which affects the handling of crimes against women.
- Overburdened constabulary: Constables form about 85% of the force but have limited role in investigation, long duty hours (often 12 hours or more) and few promotion chances.
- Political interference: Frequent transfers and postings as a tool of control weaken professionalism and impartiality.
- Custodial violence and misconduct: Illegal detention, custodial torture and deaths erode public trust. The Supreme Court has repeatedly intervened (D.K. Basu, 1997; Arnesh Kumar, 2014).
- Poor infrastructure: Shortage of vehicles, forensic support, funds for investigation and housing. Many police stations still lack proper CCTV coverage.
- Low conviction rates: Investigation and law and order duties are mixed, so investigation quality suffers.
Significance of the “Internal Reforms” Approach
- Structural reforms (new Police Acts, Security Commissions) depend on political will and have been stuck for decades. Internal reforms work within the existing system.
- Changes at the police station level are what the common citizen actually sees – how a complaint is received, how an arrested person is treated.
- Low-cost and evidence-based, since they come from field surveys of both citizens and police personnel.
- Earlier examples like Punjab’s SAANJH (community policing), Kerala’s Janamaithri Suraksha and Tamil Nadu’s Friends of Police show that such changes can work.
Challenges
- Resistance to change: Old work culture and hierarchy in police stations.
- Sustainability: Reforms often depend on individual officers and fade after transfers.
- Structural issues remain: Vacancies, political control and lack of a separate investigation wing cannot be fixed at the police station level alone.
- Digital divide: e-FIR and QR codes may not help those without smartphones or digital literacy.
- Funding: Some recommendations like tablets for IOs, vehicles and rest rooms need money, and police budgets are mostly spent on salaries.
Major Recommendations
| Committee / Commission | Year | Key Recommendations |
|---|---|---|
| National Police Commission (Dharma Vira) | 1977-81 | New Police Act; State Security Commission; fixed tenure for police chief; separation of investigation from law and order |
| Ribeiro Committee | 1998 | Review of NPC recommendations; Police Performance and Accountability Commissions |
| Malimath Committee | 2003 | Reforms in criminal justice system; separate investigation wing |
Prakash Singh vs Union of India (2006)
The Supreme Court gave seven directives to the Centre and States:
- State Security Commission to lay down broad policy and ensure the government does not exert unwarranted influence on the police.
- DGP to be selected by the State government from among the three senior-most officers empanelled by the UPSC, with a minimum tenure of two years.
- Minimum two-year tenure for officers on operational duty (IG, DIG, SP, SHO).
- Separation of investigation from law and order duties.
- Police Establishment Board to decide transfers, postings and promotions of officers of DSP rank and below.
- Police Complaints Authority at State and district levels to look into complaints of serious misconduct.
- National Security Commission at the Union level for selection and placement of chiefs of Central Police Organisations.
- Status: Most States have complied only partly. Many passed new Police Acts that dilute the directives, for example by keeping the government’s control over Security Commissions or making Complaints Authorities ineffective.
Steps Taken under New Criminal Laws (BNSS, 2023)
- e-FIR and Zero FIR (Section 173): Information can be given electronically; it is taken on record once signed by the informant within three days. FIR can be lodged at any police station irrespective of jurisdiction.
- Videography (Section 105): Search and seizure to be recorded through audio-video means. The e-Sakshya app helps police record and upload such evidence.
- Forensics (Section 176(3)): Forensic experts must visit the crime scene for offences punishable with seven years or more.
- Arrest safeguards: Information about arrests to be displayed at police stations and district control rooms; the arrested person can inform a relative or friend.
- Other judicial push: In Paramvir Singh Saini (2020), the Supreme Court directed CCTV cameras with night vision and audio in all police stations.
Way Forward
IPF Manual Recommendations
| Focus Area | Key Recommendations |
|---|---|
| 1. Complaint/FIR registration and police response | Better use of e-FIR under BNSS; Visitor Management System (VMS) for digital records at entry; help desks; QR codes at police stations for feedback |
| 2. Crime prevention, community outreach and citizen services | Night safety escorts for working women; QR codes and panic buttons in taxis linked to district control rooms; body-worn and dash cameras; more CCTV; citizen sentinel scheme; student internships; skill training for school drop-outs and drug addicts |
| 3. Prevention of misconduct and harassment | Scrutiny of reasons for arrest at DySP level; phone call for the accused after arrest; informing about right to free legal aid; videography of personal search; online monitoring of lock-ups by senior officers |
| 4. Working conditions of police stations | Rest rooms and weekly offs; transport and vehicle allowance for IOs; contingency funds for investigation; a tablet for every IO for the e-Sakshya app; recruitment board; soft-skill training; police e-academy; involving constables in investigation |
- Implement Prakash Singh directives in letter and spirit: with real independence of Security Commissions and Complaints Authorities.
- Replace the 1861 Act: States should adopt laws on the lines of the Model Police Act, 2006.
- Fill vacancies and increase women’s representation: with time-bound recruitment through independent recruitment boards.
- Separate investigation wing: with forensic support, to improve conviction rates.
- Institutionalise internal reforms: turn the change manual into standing orders and SOPs, with regular citizen feedback and third-party audits.
Police reform is not only about laws and commissions. Real change happens when a citizen walks into a police station without fear. The IPF’s change manual is a practical step in this direction, but it must be backed by structural reforms and political will.
Practice MCQ
Q1. With reference to the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, consider the following statements:
- Information about a cognizable offence can be given through electronic communication, which is taken on record once signed by the informant within three days.
- The process of search and seizure is to be recorded through audio-video electronic means.
- A forensic expert must visit the crime scene for offences punishable with imprisonment of seven years or more.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
(a) 1 only
(b) 2 only
(c) 1 and 2 only
(d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer: (d)
Explanation: All three are correct – Section 173(1), Section 105 and Section 176(3) of the BNSS respectively.
Practice Question
“Police reforms in India have largely remained on paper despite the Supreme Court’s directions in the Prakash Singh case (2006).” In this context, discuss how internal reforms at the police station level can complement structural reforms in making policing citizen-centric. (15 Marks, 250 words)
Tell Google you want more of this.
Add Anantam IAS as a preferred sourceOne tap, and this site shows up more often in your own Top Stories, AI Overviews and AI Mode. Remove it any time.