Why in news?
Recent terror incidents in Kulgam and Kishtwar have revived the debate on restoring Statehood to Jammu and Kashmir.
UPSC Relevance
Prelims – Article 3 and 4, Union Territories, J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019
Mains, GS2, Issues and Challenges Pertaining to the Federal Structure; Functions and Responsibilities of the Union and the States
GS3, Security Challenges and their Management in Border Areas; Linkages between Development and Spread of Extremism
Present Status of Jammu and Kashmir
Jammu and Kashmir was a State from the time of its accession in 1947 until 2019. On 5 August 2019, Article 370 was made inoperative and the J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019 split the State into two Union Territories (UTs) – J&K with a legislature and Ladakh without one.
- UT with legislature: Section 13 of the Reorganisation Act applies Article 239A (the Puducherry model) to J&K. The Assembly has 90 elected members, and the LG can nominate up to 5 more (including two Kashmiri migrants and one person displaced from PoJK).
- Limited law-making power: Under Section 32, the Assembly can make laws on State and Concurrent List subjects, except “public order” and “police” (Entries 1 and 2 of the State List).
- LG’s discretion: Under Section 53, the LG acts in his own discretion on police, public order, All India Services and the Anti-Corruption Bureau.
- Financial control: Bills with financial implications need the LG’s prior recommendation. As a UT, J&K is outside regular Finance Commission tax devolution and depends on grants routed through the MHA.
- Business Rules pending: Rules of business framed by the elected government are still awaiting Central approval, leaving the division of work between the CM and LG unclear.
This was the first time in independent India that a full State was downgraded to a UT. The Centre promised that Statehood would return at an “appropriate time”. More than seven years later, that promise is still pending.
Full State vs. UT of J&K
| Aspect | Full State | UT of J&K (present) |
|---|---|---|
| Head | Governor, generally bound by aid and advice of the Council of Ministers (Article 163) | Lieutenant Governor, acts in his discretion in key areas |
| Police and public order | Under the elected State government | Under the LG, i.e., effectively the MHA |
| Civil services and ACB | Postings and transfers by the State government | Controlled by the LG |
| Finances | Share in central taxes as per Finance Commission | Grants from the Centre through MHA |
| Legislative power | Entire State List and Concurrent List | All except police and public order |
| Accountability | Elected government answerable for law and order | Elected government answerable to people but without matching powers |
Why is there a Demand for Statehood?
- A promise made to the people and the Court: The Centre’s assurance was recorded by the Supreme Court, and it was repeated during the 2024 election campaign. Delay hurts the credibility of the Union’s word.
- Two centres of power: The elected government is answerable to voters but has no control over police, senior bureaucracy or anti-corruption machinery. As the Kulgam operation showed, the CM has no say even when civilian areas face prolonged restrictions.
- Respect for the people’s mandate: Voter turnout of about 64% in 2024 showed faith in democracy. If elected leaders cannot deliver, that faith may weaken and give space to separatist narratives.
- Federalism as basic structure: The Court in S.R. Bommai (1994) held federalism to be part of the basic structure. Keeping a former State as a UT for long sets a precedent that any State could be downgraded.
- Accountable bureaucracy: In GNCTD vs Union of India (2023), the Supreme Court explained the “triple chain of accountability” – civil servants to ministers, ministers to the legislature, legislature to the people. In J&K this chain is broken.
- Peace is more than absence of violence: Terror incidents and local recruitment have fallen, but alienation remains. A political voice is needed to convert security gains into lasting peace.
- Fiscal autonomy and development: Statehood would bring J&K under Finance Commission devolution and give the elected government freedom to plan for local needs.
- Strategic messaging: A fully democratic J&K strengthens India’s position against Pakistan’s propaganda on Kashmir at international forums.
Challenges and Apprehensions
- Fragile security situation: The Pahalgam attack (April 2025), the Red Fort blast in Delhi (November 2025) and the shift of militancy towards the Jammu region (Poonch, Rajouri, Kathua, Doda, Kishtwar) make the Centre cautious about handing over police.
- Need for unified command: Security agencies argue that counter-terror operations need a single chain of command; a change in control may slow intelligence sharing and operations.
- Fear of reversal of post-2019 changes: A State legislature could revisit domicile rules, land laws and other changes made after 2019.
- Trust deficit: References to the 2000 autonomy resolution and the “pre-1953 position” in the Assembly resolution raised fears that Statehood may become a step towards reviving Article 370.
- Regional divide: Jammu and Kashmir regions have different political priorities. Some voices in Jammu fear Kashmir-centric governance; some demand a separate Jammu State.
- Ladakh question: Ladakh’s own agitation for Sixth Schedule status and Statehood (including the violence in Leh in September 2025) complicates a uniform solution.
- No timeline: Neither the 2023 judgment nor later hearings fixed a deadline. The Centre continues to use “appropriate time”, which is vague.
- Financial burden: As a State, J&K would have to fund its own police and administration, while it already depends heavily on Central grants.
Supreme Court’s Stance
- In Re: Article 370 (2023): A five-judge bench unanimously upheld the abrogation, holding Article 370 to be a temporary provision.
- It upheld the creation of Ladakh as a UT under Article 3, but did not decide whether Parliament can convert an entire State into a UT, since the Solicitor General assured that Statehood would be restored.
- It directed that Statehood be restored “at the earliest and as soon as possible” and that elections be held by 30 September 2024.
- Justice S.K. Kaul recommended an impartial Truth and Reconciliation Commission to look into human rights violations by State and non-State actors since the 1980s.
- Hearings on time-bound restoration (2024-26): Petitioners argued that delay violates federalism. The Court observed that security realities must be weighed and the decision lies largely with the government, but it has kept the matter alive by seeking the Centre’s response.
- Key takeaway: The Court has relied on the executive’s assurance rather than ordering a deadline. This leaves an open constitutional question – can a State be kept as a UT indefinitely?
Constitutional Route for Restoration
- Statehood can be restored by Parliament through an ordinary law under Articles 3 and 4 (amending the Reorganisation Act). Such a law is not a constitutional amendment under Article 368 (Article 4(2)).
- Only a simple majority is needed in both Houses; the Bill requires the President’s prior recommendation.
Way Forward
- Clear timeline: The Centre should announce a roadmap in Parliament and inform the Supreme Court, ending uncertainty.
- Phased transfer of powers: Experts suggest restoring Statehood with a transition period in which counter-terror operations remain coordinated with the Centre, while normal policing moves to the State.
- Use of existing models: Article 371A gives the Governor of Nagaland special responsibility for law and order. A similar time-bound arrangement can address security concerns without denying Statehood.
- Revive the Unified Headquarters chaired by the CM: This pre-2019 model gave the elected leader a role in security planning while keeping Army and CAPFs in the loop.
- Immediate steps: Approve the Business Rules, consult the CM on key postings and avoid collective restrictions on civilians during operations.
- Keep Statehood separate from Article 370: Regional parties can build wider consensus by treating Statehood as a democratic and federal issue, not a reversal of 2019.
- Dialogue and reconciliation: Structured talks with all stakeholders – Jammu, Kashmir, Kashmiri Pandits and youth – along with a Truth and Reconciliation process, as suggested by Justice Kaul.
- Fiscal integration: Bring J&K under the Finance Commission framework with a special grant for security expenditure during the transition.
Security operations have reduced violence, but peace needs legitimacy. Restoring Statehood with sensible safeguards will show that national security and democratic self-rule in J&K are not opposed to each other but support each other.
Practice MCQ
Q1. With reference to Jammu and Kashmir, consider the following statements:
- Restoration of Statehood to Jammu and Kashmir requires a constitutional amendment under Article 368.
- Under the J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019, the Legislative Assembly of J&K cannot make laws on “police” and “public order”.
- In In Re: Article 370 (2023), the Supreme Court held that Parliament has the power to convert a State into a Union Territory under Article 3.
How many of the statements given above are correct?
(a) Only one
(b) Only two
(c) All three
(d) None
Answer: (a)
Explanation: Statement 1 is incorrect – a law under Articles 3 and 4 is not treated as an amendment under Article 368 (Article 4(2)). Statement 3 is incorrect – the Court left this question open, relying on the Centre’s assurance. Statement 2 is correct (Section 32 of the Act).
Q2. Given below are two statements, one labelled as Assertion (A) and the other as Reason (R):
- Assertion (A): In the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir, the elected government does not control the police.
- Reason (R): Article 239AA of the Constitution, which applies to Delhi, has been extended to Jammu and Kashmir.
In the light of the above statements, choose the correct option:
(a) Both (A) and (R) are correct, and (R) is the correct explanation of (A).
(b) Both (A) and (R) are correct, but (R) is NOT the correct explanation of (A).
(c) (A) is correct, but (R) is incorrect.
(d) (A) is incorrect, but (R) is correct.
Answer: (c)
Explanation: Section 13 of the J&K Reorganisation Act applies Article 239A (as for Puducherry), not Article 239AA. Police is outside the Assembly’s powers under Section 32 and under the LG’s discretion under Section 53.
Practice Question
“The restoration of Statehood to Jammu and Kashmir is as much a question of cooperative federalism as it is of internal security.” Examine the arguments for and against early restoration of Statehood and suggest a way forward. (15 Marks, 250 words)
Tell Google you want more of this.
Add Anantam IAS as a preferred sourceOne tap, and this site shows up more often in your own Top Stories, AI Overviews and AI Mode. Remove it any time.