Indian urbanisation is generating wealth at one end and slums at the other. Examine the structural reasons for this dual outcome with reference to migration, housing and urban local governance.
Subtopic: Indian Society · Urbanisation and Urban Poor
How to structure your answer
Introduction: India’s urban share, last measured at 31.16% in Census 2011, is projected by the World Bank’s 2025 report to reach about 951 million urban Indians by 2050.
Body — three dimensions: (1) Migration: 45.36 crore migrants in Census 2011, with rural-to-urban moves driving city growth. PRS data shows over 80% of urban informal workers are migrants. (2) Housing: National Buildings Organisation puts the urban housing shortage at 1.88 crore in 2012 with 95% in EWS and LIG; PMAY-Urban 2.0 (September 2024) sanctioned around 3.53 lakh houses by mid-2025. (3) Governance: 74th Constitutional Amendment 1992 devolved 18 functions to ULBs but state finance commissions remain weak; municipal own revenue is 1% of GDP against the global 7%.
Conclusion: The Isher Judge Ahluwalia HPEC 2011 report’s estimate of ₹39 lakh crore in urban investment over 20 years is still the benchmark; without fiscal devolution to ULBs the dual city will harden.
Written within the word limit
225 words · target 250 words · 14 min
Introduction:
India's urban share, last measured at 31.16 per cent in Census 2011, is projected by the World Bank's 2025 urban report to reach about 951 million urban Indians by 2050. As Mike Davis warned in Planet of Slums, the same growth engine can generate skyscrapers and informal settlements on adjacent plots — and India is now its leading test case.
Migration:
Census 2011 recorded 45.36 crore internal migrants; PRS Legislative Research data show over 80 per cent of urban informal workers are migrants. Bengaluru's Mahadevapura ward — an IT corridor abutting informal settlements — is the visible illustration of this dual pattern.
Housing:
The National Buildings Organisation estimated the urban housing shortage at 1.88 crore in 2012, with 95 per cent in the EWS and LIG categories. PMAY-Urban (launched 25 June 2015) and PMAY-U 2.0 (September 2024) have sanctioned around 3.53 lakh houses by mid-2025, but Dharavi redevelopment and the Chennai Perumbakkam resettlement after the 2015 floods show how supply still lags need.
Urban local governance:
The 74th Constitutional Amendment of 1992 devolved 18 functions to Urban Local Bodies via the Twelfth Schedule, but state finance commissions remain weak; municipal own revenue is about 1 per cent of GDP against the global benchmark of 7 per cent, starving cities of capital.
Conclusion:
Isher Judge Ahluwalia's HPEC 2011 estimate of ₹39 lakh crore in urban investment over 20 years remains the benchmark. Without genuine fiscal devolution to ULBs and an in-situ upgrading approach to slums, India's dual city will harden into permanence.
What an examiner expects to see
- Census 2011: 31.16% urban; no Census since
- World Bank 2025 report — 951 million urban Indians by 2050
- Internal migrants 45.36 crore (Census 2011)
- Urban housing shortage 1.88 crore (NBO 2012)
- PMAY-Urban launched 25 June 2015; PMAY-U 2.0 September 2024
- 74th Constitutional Amendment 1992, Twelfth Schedule, 18 functions
- ULB own-revenue c. 1% of GDP
- Isher Judge Ahluwalia HPEC report, 2011 — ₹39 lakh crore over 20 years
- Mike Davis ‘Planet of Slums’ framing
Concrete cases, schemes and judgments
- Dharavi redevelopment in Mumbai
- Bengaluru’s Mahadevapura ward, IT corridor adjacent to slums
- Delhi’s informal settlements along the Yamuna khadar
- Chennai’s resettlement at Perumbakkam after 2015 floods