UPSC CSE 2026 Essay Paper Discussion
GS Paper 2 15 marks · 250w 14 min Medium

NITI Aayog at 10 has been an instrument of cooperative federalism but has not replaced the planning function. With reference to its Governing Council and the Aspirational Districts Programme, examine.

Subtopic: Governance · Government Policies & Interventions

Model answer outline

How to structure your answer

Introduction: NITI Aayog replaced the Planning Commission on 1 January 2015 by a Union Cabinet resolution — a non-statutory, non-constitutional think-tank with the Prime Minister as Chair and Chief Ministers as Governing Council members.

Body: Three dimensions — (i) governance architecture — Governing Council (apex), CEO, sectoral verticals, Three Year Action Agenda (2017), Strategy for New India @ 75; (ii) cooperative federalism instruments — Aspirational Districts Programme launched 5 January 2018 covering 112 districts, Aspirational Blocks Programme (500 blocks, January 2023), SDG India Index, Health Index and Composite Water Management Index; (iii) gaps — no resource-allocation power (transferred to the Finance Ministry), declining attendance at Governing Council meetings (some CMs boycotted the 9th meeting on 27 July 2024), and absence of a statutory base under Article 263.

Way forward / Conclusion: A statutory NITI Aayog under Article 263 with binding minimum standards for index data, a clear resource-coordination role with Finance Commission and concurrent-list mandate areas would consolidate the cooperative-federalism gains of the first decade.

Full model answer

Written within the word limit

218 words · target 250 words · 14 min

Introduction:

NITI Aayog replaced the Planning Commission on 1 January 2015 by a Union Cabinet resolution as a non-statutory, non-constitutional think-tank with the Prime Minister as Chair and Chief Ministers in the Governing Council; at ten, it has advanced cooperative federalism but has not replaced the planning function.

Governance architecture: The Governing Council anchors federal coordination; the Three Year Action Agenda (2017) and Strategy for New India @ 75 are flagship documents; sectoral verticals, the CEO and a network of resource institutions drive operations, with the 2nd ARC's Fifteenth Report having recommended an institutional replacement for the Planning Commission.

Cooperative federalism instruments: The Aspirational Districts Programme launched 5 January 2018 covering 112 districts, the Aspirational Blocks Programme of January 2023 covering 500 blocks, the SDG India Index (since 2018), the Health Index (Kerala-led for 2021-22) and the Composite Water Management Index institutionalise State-level data, competition and convergence.

Gaps: NITI Aayog has no resource-allocation power (transferred to the Finance Ministry); attendance at the Governing Council has thinned, with several Chief Ministers boycotting the 9th meeting on 27 July 2024; and the absence of an Article 263 statutory base weakens its standing alongside the GST Council and Inter-State Council.

Way forward / Conclusion:

A statutory NITI Aayog under Article 263 with binding minimum standards for index data, clear resource-coordination with the Finance Commission, and concurrent-list mandate areas would consolidate the cooperative-federalism gains of the first decade.

Key points

What an examiner expects to see

  • NITI Aayog established 1 January 2015 by Union Cabinet resolution
  • Governing Council — PM as Chair, all CMs as members
  • Aspirational Districts Programme launched 5 January 2018 — 112 districts
  • Aspirational Blocks Programme launched January 2023 — 500 blocks
  • SDG India Index (since 2018) and Composite Water Management Index
  • 9th Governing Council meeting held 27 July 2024
  • 2nd ARC Fifteenth Report had recommended an institutional replacement for the Planning Commission
Examples to use

Concrete cases, schemes and judgments

  • Aspirational Districts Programme 2018
  • Aspirational Blocks Programme 2023
  • SDG India Index 2023-24
  • Health Index 2021-22 — Kerala top performer
  • Composite Water Management Index
Keywords / terms

Terminology to weave into the answer

NITI AayogAspirational Districtscooperative federalismGoverning CouncilSDG IndexArticle 263Planning Commission
Sources to read

Primary sources and verified references

10 Years of NITI Aayog (2015-2025) — Anantam IAS https://anantamias.com/10-years-of-niti-aayog-2015-2025/ NITI Aayog — Anantam IAS https://anantamias.com/niti-aayog/ Planning Commission vs NITI Aayog — Anantam IAS https://anantamias.com/planning-commission-vs-niti-aayog/

Share this answer