UPSC CSE 2026 Essay Paper Discussion
GS Paper 2 10 marks · 200w 14 min Hard

The proposed withdrawal of International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) from Afghanistan in 2014 is fraught with major security implications for the countries of the region. Examine in light of the fact that India is faced with a plethora of challenges and needs to safeguard its own strategic interests.

Subtopic: International Relations · Afghanistan, regional security and India's interests

Model answer outline

How to structure your answer

Introduction (ISAF drawdown, December 2014) → regional security implications → India-specific challenges (investments, personnel, access, Kashmir spillover) → steps to safeguard strategic interests → hindsight from 2021 → Conclusion
Full model answer

Written within the word limit

225 words · target 200 words · 14 min

Introduction

The NATO-led International Security Assistance Force ended combat operations in Afghanistan in December 2014, leaving security primarily to Afghan forces. The drawdown carried grave implications for a region already destabilised by insurgency, and posed a direct test for India's Afghan policy.

Regional security implications

  • Taliban resurgence and contested territory, with the risk of state collapse.
  • Revival of terrorist safe havens for groups such as LeT and JeM, and Pakistan's pursuit of 'strategic depth'.
  • Expansion of Golden Crescent narcotics networks that finance militancy.
  • Spillover of instability into Central Asia, and a power vacuum drawing in China, Iran and Russia.

India's specific challenges

  • Protecting over $3 billion of development investment — the Zaranj-Delaram highway, the Salma (Friendship) Dam and the Afghan Parliament — and the safety of Indian personnel after attacks such as Herat (2014).
  • Denial of overland access by Pakistan, forcing reliance on the Iran-Chabahar route.
  • Possible diversion of battle-hardened fighters and networks towards Jammu and Kashmir.

Safeguarding strategic interests

  • The India-Afghanistan Strategic Partnership Agreement (2011): training Afghan security forces and capacity building.
  • Regional diplomacy through the Heart of Asia process and coordination with Iran, Russia and Central Asian republics.
  • Developing Chabahar port to retain connectivity to Afghanistan.

Conclusion

The 2021 US withdrawal and Taliban takeover ultimately confirmed these apprehensions. India's calibrated response — humanitarian wheat and medicine shipments and a technical mission in Kabul since 2022, without formal recognition — shows that patient, interest-based engagement remains the sound course.

Key points

What an examiner expects to see

  • The ISAF combat mission ended in December 2014; the residual Resolute Support mission left Afghan forces overstretched against a resurgent Taliban.
  • Regional fallout: terror safe havens (LeT, JeM), Pakistan's 'strategic depth' doctrine, Golden Crescent narcotics financing militancy, Central Asian instability.
  • India-specific stakes: over $3 billion of development projects (Zaranj-Delaram highway, Salma Dam, Parliament building) and personnel security after the Herat consulate attack (2014).
  • Connectivity constraint: Pakistan denies overland transit, making Chabahar India's strategic answer for Afghan access.
  • Policy toolkit: 2011 Strategic Partnership Agreement, training of Afghan forces, Heart of Asia diplomacy, coordination with Iran and Russia.
  • Hindsight strengthens the answer: the August 2021 Taliban takeover validated the premise; India now engages through humanitarian aid and a technical mission without recognition.
Examples to use

Concrete cases, schemes and judgments

  • Zaranj-Delaram highway (Route 218) built by the Border Roads Organisation
  • Salma Dam — the India-Afghanistan Friendship Dam, inaugurated 2016
  • Afghan Parliament building gifted by India, inaugurated 2015
  • Attack on the Indian consulate in Herat, May 2014
  • India-Afghanistan Strategic Partnership Agreement, October 2011
  • 50,000 tonnes of wheat aid to Afghanistan and the reopened technical mission in Kabul (2022)
Keywords / terms

Terminology to weave into the answer

ISAF drawdownstrategic depthGolden CrescentChabaharHeart of Asia processengagement without recognition

Share this answer