Why in news?
A recent analysis points out that output per worker in AI-adopting sectors of the US economy (information, finance and insurance, professional and business services) has risen sharply above its pre-2020 trend. This has revived the debate on whether AI will raise growth for everyone or only raise output while pushing workers out of jobs.
UPSC Relevance
Mains, GS3 – Indian Economy and issues relating to Planning, Mobilization of Resources, Growth, Development and Employment; Science and Technology – developments and their applications and effects in everyday life
What is Labour Productivity?
Labour productivity is the ratio of output to the number of workers employed.
Labour productivity = Output ÷ Workers employed
This ratio can rise in three ways:
- Output rises while the number of workers stays the same.
- Jobs are lost, so the denominator falls.
- Both output and jobs grow, but output grows faster than jobs.
The third case is the most desirable for any economy. AI may replace some white-collar work but create new jobs elsewhere, so the net effect on employment is not yet settled. What is clear is that AI is expected to raise productivity, and its success as a technology depends on that rise.
What does the data show?
- In US AI-adopting sectors, real output per worker (indexed to 100 in Q1 2012) reached about 148 by Q2 2026, against about 121 had the 2012–19 trend continued.
- The gap opened mainly after 2020, when digital and AI tools spread faster across services.
- The bigger question is how far this gain will spread to agriculture, manufacturing and other services.
Two Schools of Thought: Does Productivity Create Jobs?
| Aspect | Neoclassical (Supply-side) View | Heterodox (Demand-side) View |
|---|---|---|
| Core idea | Output growth = growth of labour force + growth of labour productivity | Output is produced only if it is demanded; productivity alone does not guarantee growth |
| Example | Workforce grows 2%, productivity 4% → economy grows 6% | Demand grows 3%, productivity 4% → jobs fall by 1% |
| Message for AI | AI-led productivity will lift growth almost automatically | AI will create jobs only if demand grows faster than productivity |
Labour as a global reserve: The demand-side view also says labour is never truly scarce. Historically, the Atlantic slave trade and indentured labour moved workers to colonies. Today, Punjab draws farm workers from Bihar and UP, and Silicon Valley relaxes work visas when it needs engineers. When job growth slows, borders close – which partly explains rising anti-immigrant politics in the global North.
How AI will alter Labour Productivity
- Automation of routine tasks: Data entry, basic coding, document review and customer queries can be done faster and at lower cost.
- Augmentation of workers: AI acts as a co-pilot – a doctor reads scans faster, a teacher prepares lessons quicker, a lawyer searches case law in minutes.
- Faster innovation: AI speeds up drug discovery, material science and weather forecasting, raising productivity of research itself (the endogenous growth channel).
- Better use of capital: Predictive maintenance, smart logistics and precision farming reduce waste of machines, inputs and time.
- Lower cost of knowledge: Expertise that was costly earlier (translation, design, analysis) becomes cheap and widely available, including in regional languages.
Sector-wise Impact
| Sector | How AI changes productivity | Effect on jobs |
|---|---|---|
| Agriculture | Crop advisories, soil and weather prediction, drone spraying, price forecasting | Better farm incomes; limited direct job loss as work is manual; need for agri-tech skills |
| Manufacturing | Robotics, quality checks through computer vision, predictive maintenance | Fewer assembly-line jobs; new jobs in maintenance and robotics |
| IT and BPM services | Code generation, testing, automated customer support | Most exposed in India; pressure on entry-level coders and call-centre jobs; demand for AI engineers |
| Banking and Finance | Credit scoring, fraud detection, chatbots, algorithmic trading | Fewer clerical roles; more roles in risk, compliance and data |
| Healthcare | Diagnosis from scans, telemedicine, drug discovery | Augments doctors; can ease shortage in rural areas |
| Education | Personalised learning, AI tutors in local languages | Teachers’ role shifts to mentoring; content jobs change |
| Governance | Grievance redressal, fraud detection in welfare, document translation (e.g. Bhashini) | Faster delivery; fewer routine clerical posts |
| Creative and Media | Text, image, video generation | Pressure on writers, designers, translators; copyright disputes |
Why it matters more for India
- Demographic dividend: India adds millions to its workforce every year. If AI reduces entry-level jobs, the dividend can turn into a burden.The IMF (2024) estimated that nearly 40% of global employment is exposed to AI, rising to about 60% in advanced economies.
- Services-led growth model: India skipped the classic manufacturing route and grew through IT and business services – precisely the area most exposed to AI.
- Large informal sector: Most workers lack formal skills and social security, so they have little cushion against disruption.
- Opportunity side: A large talent pool, cheap data and Digital Public Infrastructure (Aadhaar, UPI) give India a chance to build AI for scale in local languages.
Challenges and Problems
- Jobless growth: Output may rise while employment stagnates, as the demand-side view warns.
- Rising inequality: Gains may flow to capital owners and a few skilled workers, widening the gap between firms, regions and workers.
- Uneven spread of productivity: Gains may stay confined to a few digital sectors, leaving agriculture and MSMEs behind.
- Skill mismatch: The education system produces degrees, not the problem-solving and digital skills AI-era jobs need.
- Market concentration: A handful of global firms control frontier models, chips and cloud compute, creating dependence for countries like India.
- Gig and platform work: New jobs may be insecure, without fixed wages, pensions or health cover.
- Bias, privacy and accountability: AI used in hiring, lending or policing can discriminate if trained on biased data.
- Restrictions on migration: As the article argues, falling labour demand in rich countries tightens visa rules, hurting Indian professionals abroad and remittances.
- Energy and environment: Data centres need large amounts of electricity and water.
Possible Solutions and Preventions
- Reskilling at scale: Expand programmes like FutureSkills PRIME and Skill India Digital; focus on lifelong learning rather than one-time degrees.
- Reform education: Implement NEP 2020’s focus on critical thinking, coding and multidisciplinary learning from school level.
- Support demand, not just supply: Public investment in health, education, care economy and infrastructure can absorb workers and keep demand growing faster than productivity.
- Social security for new workers: Effectively implement the Code on Social Security, 2020 provisions for gig and platform workers; explore portable benefits.
- Human-in-the-loop design: Encourage AI that augments workers rather than fully replaces them, especially in public services.
- Spread adoption to MSMEs and farms: Affordable AI tools, local-language models and shared compute through the IndiaAI Mission.
- Fair sharing of gains: Debate on measures such as taxing windfall AI profits or digital services to fund transition support.
- Risk-based governance: Clear rules on data protection (DPDP Act, 2023), algorithmic transparency and accountability, without choking innovation.
- Global cooperation: Push for fair access to compute, data and skilled-worker mobility in forums like G20 and the Global Partnership on AI.
Government Initiatives on AI
| Initiative | Key features |
|---|---|
| National Strategy for AI (2018) | NITI Aayog’s ‘#AIforAll’ strategy; focus areas – healthcare, agriculture, education, smart cities, mobility |
| IndiaAI Mission (2024) | Outlay of ₹10,371.92 crore; GPU compute capacity, foundation models, datasets platform, startup financing, AI skilling |
| Bhashini | AI-based translation across Indian languages for digital inclusion |
| FutureSkills PRIME | MeitY–NASSCOM platform for reskilling in emerging technologies including AI |
| Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 | Framework for lawful processing of personal data used in AI systems |
Conclusion
AI may well be as epochal as the steam engine, but productivity growth by itself does not guarantee more or better jobs. Whether AI becomes a dividend or a disruption will depend on how fast demand grows, how widely gains are shared and how quickly workers are reskilled. For India, the goal should be ‘AI for jobs’, not just ‘AI for output’.
Mains Practice Question
“Rising labour productivity due to Artificial Intelligence does not automatically translate into more jobs.” In light of this statement, discuss the impact of AI on productivity and employment across different sectors of the Indian economy, and suggest measures to ensure an inclusive transition. (15 Marks, 250 words)
Tell Google you want more of this.
Add Anantam IAS as a preferred sourceOne tap, and this site shows up more often in your own Top Stories, AI Overviews and AI Mode. Remove it any time.