Why in news?
As India marks the first anniversary of the implementation of the four Labour Codes (21 November 2025), layoffs linked to AI adoption and restructuring in the tech sector have raised questions on severance pay, its taxation and the lack of an unemployment relief system in India.
UPSC Relevance
Prelims – Labour Codes, retrenchment provisions, Article 41, e-Shram, ESIC schemes
Mains, GS2 – Welfare schemes for vulnerable sections; Mechanisms, laws and institutions for their protection and betterment
GS3 – Indian Economy and issues relating to Growth, Development and Employment; Inclusive growth
Layoff vs Retrenchment
‘Layoff’ is a term borrowed from American usage. Indian labour law uses three different terms, and the difference is important for exams:
| Term | Meaning | Nature |
|---|---|---|
| Lay-off | Employer fails or refuses to give work due to shortage of raw material, power, breakdown of machinery, etc. | Temporary; worker stays on rolls and gets 50% of wages as compensation |
| Retrenchment | Termination of service by the employer for any reason other than punishment | Permanent; excludes voluntary retirement, superannuation, end of fixed-term contract and termination due to ill-health |
| Closure | Permanent shutting down of a place of employment or a part of it | Permanent; all workers lose jobs |
In the West, a layoff usually means a pink slip, settlement of dues and exit. In India, it carries a much heavier social cost – loss of income, health cover, social standing and often a hidden sense of shame within the family.
What protections does a retrenched worker have?
Constitutional Basis
- Article 41 (DPSP): The State shall, within its economic capacity, make effective provision for securing the right to work and public assistance in cases of unemployment, old age, sickness and disablement.
- Article 43 (DPSP): Living wage and decent conditions of work for all workers.
- Entries 22, 23 and 24 of the Concurrent List: Trade unions and industrial disputes; social security and social insurance, employment and unemployment; welfare of labour.
Under the Industrial Relations Code, 2020
- Notice: One month’s written notice with reasons, or wages in lieu of notice, for a worker with at least one year of continuous service.
- Retrenchment compensation: 15 days’ average pay for every completed year of continuous service.
- Prior government permission: Needed for lay-off, retrenchment and closure only in factories, mines and plantations employing 300 or more workers (the threshold was 100 under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947).
- Worker Re-skilling Fund: The employer contributes 15 days’ last drawn wages for each retrenched worker, which is credited to the worker for re-skilling.
- Last in, first out: The worker who joined last in a category is normally retrenched first.
- Right to re-employment: Retrenched workers get preference if the employer hires again.
Under the Code on Social Security, 2020
- Gratuity: 15 days’ wages for every completed year of service; fixed-term employees now become eligible after one year instead of five.
- ESIC unemployment relief: Insured workers who lose jobs can get cash relief of a part of their average earnings for a limited period under ESIC schemes such as the Atal Bimit Vyakti Kalyan Yojana.
- Provident Fund: Partial withdrawal is allowed during unemployment.
Concerns
- Narrow coverage: The strongest protections (prior permission) apply mainly to manufacturing, mining and plantations. Services and IT workers, who have faced some of the biggest layoffs in recent years, are largely outside this net. Informal workers are left out entirely.
- Taxation of severance: Severance pay is treated as ‘profit in lieu of salary’ and taxed like salary. Critics argue that taxing a payment meant to cushion job loss weakens its purpose.
- One-time payment culture: Most Indian employers prefer to pay compensation in one go and close the file. Progressive practice abroad also includes counselling, legal advice, retraining and help with job search.
- Gig, platform and informal workers: How to compensate for loss of earning potential when income itself is irregular.
- Dispute resolution: The IR Code replaced Labour Courts with Industrial Tribunals. Whether vacancies are filled on time and tribunals work efficiently remains to be seen.
- Reforms seen as employer-friendly: Critics feel the Codes were driven mainly by ease of doing business and attracting investment, with workers’ concerns secondary.
- Weak health cover after job loss: ESI hospitals are too few compared to the number of beneficiaries.
- No unemployment relief system: India has no general unemployment insurance. The joint family once acted as a cushion, but this support is weakening with urbanisation and nuclear families.
How other countries protect workers
| Country | Model |
|---|---|
| Germany | Earnings-linked unemployment insurance – payout is a percentage of the worker’s previous earnings, not a flat rate |
| USA | Unemployment insurance funded through payroll tax; employer’s rate based on ‘experience rating’ (history of past layoffs); run jointly by federal and state governments |
| UK | Jobseeker’s Allowance and Universal Credit linked to job search |
| Singapore | SkillsFuture Jobseeker Support – temporary financial help linked to training and job search |
| Sri Lanka and many European countries | Stricter rules and procedures on termination than India |
Way Forward
- Unemployment insurance for India: A contributory scheme, possibly built on ESIC and EPFO, with payouts linked to past earnings and conditional on re-skilling and job search.
- Extend retrenchment safeguards to services and IT: Advance notice, transition support and counselling, irrespective of sector.
- Rethink taxation of severance: A higher tax exemption limit for retrenchment compensation would make it a real cushion.
- Make the Re-skilling Fund work: Link it to Skill India and industry-led courses, with tracking of re-employment outcomes.
- Portable benefits for gig workers: Use e-Shram and Aadhaar-linked accounts so benefits move with the worker across platforms. One suggestion is a small voluntary premium paid by the gig worker and matched by the aggregator and the customer.
- Urban employment guarantee: Rural India has MGNREGA/VB-GRAM-G; urban schemes need different design (skills, wages, type of work).
- Strengthen ESI infrastructure: More hospitals and dispensaries in industrial and urban clusters.
- Two-pronged approach: Bring workers into the formal social security net, and build synergy between citizens and government agencies. Labour market governance may increasingly shift towards the Skills Ministry.
Conclusion
AI-driven restructuring will make job loss a more frequent part of working life, especially for white-collar and gig workers. India has a good set of laws and institutions on paper, but the real gap lies in coverage and implementation. A modern labour market needs not just flexibility for employers, but a dependable safety net that helps workers move from one job to the next.
Practice MCQ
Q1. With reference to the Industrial Relations Code, 2020, consider the following statements:
- Industrial establishments employing 300 or more workers need prior permission of the appropriate government before retrenchment.
- A retrenched worker is entitled to compensation of 15 days’ average pay for every completed year of continuous service.
- The Code retains Labour Courts along with Industrial Tribunals for settling disputes.
Which of the statements given above are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only
(b) 2 and 3 only
(c) 1 and 3 only
(d) 1, 2 and 3
Answer: (a)
Explanation: Statement 3 is incorrect. The Code has done away with Labour Courts; disputes now go to Industrial Tribunals.
Q2. Which Article of the Constitution of India directs the State to make effective provision for public assistance in cases of unemployment?
(a) Article 39A
(b) Article 41
(c) Article 43
(d) Article 47
Answer: (b)
Explanation: Article 41 deals with the right to work, to education and to public assistance in certain cases. Article 39A is on free legal aid, Article 43 on living wage and Article 47 on nutrition and public health.
Mains Practice Question
“With AI-driven layoffs on the rise, India’s retrenchment framework protects too few workers and offers too little support.” Critically examine the safeguards available to workers under the new Labour Codes and suggest a suitable model of unemployment protection for India. (15 Marks, 250 words)
Tell Google you want more of this.
Add Anantam IAS as a preferred sourceOne tap, and this site shows up more often in your own Top Stories, AI Overviews and AI Mode. Remove it any time.