UPSC CSE 2026 Essay Paper Discussion
GS Paper 3 10 marks · 150w 9 min Medium

India’s gene-editing classification of SDN-1, SDN-2 and SDN-3 has carved out a non-GM exemption route. Discuss the science and the policy implications for Indian agriculture.

Subtopic: Sci-Tech · Biotechnology and IPR

Model answer outline

How to structure your answer

Introduction: MoEFCC office memorandum (March 2022) exempts SDN-1 and SDN-2 edits without foreign DNA from Rules 1989 GM-organism regulation; backed by DBT 2022 guidelines for safety assessment of genome-edited plants.

Body: 1) Science — SDN-1 no template (knock-out), SDN-2 small template (point edits), SDN-3 large insert (transgene). 2) Implications — Kamala and Pusa DST Rice 1 (4 May 2025) released under SDN-1 exemption; faster regulatory pathway. 3) Concerns — civil-society challenge to exemption; lack of segregation in seed system.

Way forward: Statutory backing via Biotechnology Regulatory Authority Bill; mandatory PPV&FR Act 2001 registration of edited varieties; transparent biosafety dossiers.

Full model answer

Written within the word limit

135 words · target 150 words · 9 min

Introduction: An MoEFCC office memorandum of March 2022 exempts SDN-1 and SDN-2 genome edits without foreign DNA from the GM-organism regulation under Rules 1989; DBT Safety Assessment Guidelines for Genome Edited Plants (2022) provide the science backbone.

Body: First, the science — SDN-1 introduces targeted breaks with no template (knock-out), SDN-2 uses small templates for point edits, SDN-3 inserts large transgenes; only SDN-3 falls under the EPA 1986 GMO framework. Second, policy impact — Kamala (DRR Dhan 100) and Pusa DST Rice 1 were released on 4 May 2025 under the SDN-1 exemption, yielding ~19% gains. Third, the Supreme Court split verdict on GM mustard DMH-11 (July 2024) directed a National GM Crop Policy; civil-society groups challenge the SDN exemption over inadequate consultation.

Way forward: Pass the Biotechnology Regulatory Authority Bill, mandate PPV&FR Act 2001 registration of edited varieties, and publish transparent biosafety dossiers by 2027 under DBT.

Key points

What an examiner expects to see

  • MoEFCC OM March 2022 exempts SDN-1 and SDN-2 from Rules 1989
  • Kamala (DRR Dhan 100) and Pusa DST Rice 1 released 4 May 2025
  • DBT Safety Assessment Guidelines for Genome Edited Plants 2022
  • SDN-1 ~19% yield gain (Kamala), 20% lower emissions
  • Supreme Court split on DMH-11 GM mustard July 2024
  • GEAC under Rules 1989 of EPA 1986
Examples to use

Concrete cases, schemes and judgments

  • CRISPR-Cas9 system
  • ICAR-IARI and ICAR-IIRR breeding pipelines
  • PPV&FR Act 2001 farmers' rights
Keywords / terms

Terminology to weave into the answer

SDN-1CRISPRGEACRules 1989KamalaPPV&FRbiosafety
Sources to read

Primary sources and verified references

DBT — Genome-edited plants guidelines https://dbtindia.gov.in/ Anantam IAS — SDN-1 SDN-2 SDN-3 Techniques https://anantamias.com/sdn-1-sdn-2-sdn-3-site-directed-nuclease-techniques/ Anantam IAS — Gene Therapy vs Gene Editing https://anantamias.com/gene-therapy-vs-gene-editing/

Share this answer