GS Paper 2 10 marks · 150w 9 min Medium
“India’s relations with Israel have, of late, acquired a depth and diversity, which cannot be rolled back.” Discuss.
Subtopic: International Relations · India–Israel strategic partnership
How to structure your answer
Introduction → 1992 normalisation to the 2017 prime ministerial visit and de-hyphenation → Depth: defence, counter-terrorism, agriculture and water → Diversity: trade, innovation (I4F), I2U2, IMEC, Haifa Port → Structural drivers of irreversibility alongside India's continuing balance on Palestine → Conclusion
Detailed model answer
204 words · target 150 words · 9 min
Full diplomatic relations, established only in 1992, have matured into a strategic partnership since the first Indian prime ministerial visit to Israel in 2017 and the conscious 'de-hyphenation' of ties with Israel from the Palestine question.
Depth and diversity of the relationship
- Defence and security: India is among the largest buyers of Israeli defence equipment — co-developed Barak-8 missiles, UAVs and radars — backed by close counter-terrorism and intelligence cooperation.
- Agriculture and water: around 30 Indo-Israel Centres of Excellence spread drip irrigation and horticulture technology across Indian states.
- Innovation and commerce: the India-Israel Industrial R&D Fund (I4F), bilateral trade of roughly USD 10 billion, and Adani's operation of Haifa Port since 2023.
- Plurilateral layer: the I2U2 grouping (India-Israel-UAE-US) and the proposed India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor embed the bilateral tie in wider regional architecture.
Why it is hard to roll back
- The drivers are structural, not sentimental — technology needs, defence supply chains and convergence on terrorism outlast changes of government in either country.
- Yet India retains its balance: it supports a two-state solution, votes independently at the UN, and has sent humanitarian aid to Palestinians even while security cooperation with Israel continues.
The relationship is now interest-driven and institutionalised rather than ideological — which is precisely why its depth and diversity endure.
What an examiner expects to see
- Ties were normalised only in 1992; the 2017 prime ministerial visit and de-hyphenation from the Palestine question marked strategic maturity.
- Defence is the anchor: Barak-8 co-development, UAVs and radars, with India among the largest buyers of Israeli arms.
- Agriculture and water cooperation through about 30 Centres of Excellence delivers visible domestic value to Indian farmers.
- New geometry — I2U2 and the India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor — embeds the bilateral relationship in regional architecture.
- Irreversibility flows from structural interests: technology dependence, security convergence and institutionalised mechanisms.
- India still balances: support for a two-state solution, independent UN votes, ties with Iran and the Gulf, humanitarian aid to Palestinians.
Concrete cases, schemes and judgments
- Barak-8 surface-to-air missile co-development
- I2U2 grouping (India–Israel–UAE–US)
- Adani-operated Haifa Port (2023)
- Indo-Israel Centres of Excellence under the Indo-Israel Agriculture Project
- India-Israel Industrial R&D Fund (I4F)
Terminology to weave into the answer
de-hyphenationstrategic partnershipdefence cooperationI2U2IMECtwo-state solution