Five Years of Taliban Rule: Afghanistan at Crossroads

Why in News?

August 15, 2026 marked five years since the Taliban re-established the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan (IEA). Its record has been binary: greater internal stability accompanied by severe socio-political regression and continuing economic fragility.

Afghanistan: Stable but Repressive State

• Afghanistan has experienced a marked decline in large-scale armed conflict since 2021. Taliban avoided widespread retributive violence and managed the return of nearly six million Afghans from Iran and Pakistan, despite the pressure on employment, housing and public services.
• Threats from Islamic State-Khorasan Province, al-Qaeda and Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan persist. Taliban’s claim that Afghan territory is no longer used by terrorist groups remains contested. 
• Politically, the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan (IEA) is an uncodified, centralised theocracy headed by Supreme Leader Hibatullah Akhundzada. Its narrow power structure excludes women and provides limited representation to non-Pashtuns and minorities. 
• Women’s Rights: The sharpest regression concerns women’s rights-
  • Girls cannot pursue formal education beyond Class VI
  • Women are barred from universities and most employment
  • Their movement and participation in public life are severely restricted; and
  • Gender segregation and risks of child marriage have increased.

Afghanistan remains the only country where secondary and higher education are effectively closed to girls and women. These restrictions violate the spirit of the 2020 Doha Agreement and UNSC Resolution 2593, which calls for counter-terrorism, human rights and an inclusive political settlement.

Fragile Economic Recovery: 

• The economy has recovered modestly after contracting by nearly 20% following the Taliban takeover. Better revenue collection, a relatively stable currency and activity in agriculture, mining and services have supported growth.
• The World Bank estimated growth at about 4.8% in 2025, but rapid population expansion caused per-capita income to decline by around 5.6%. Poverty, food insecurity, weak banking, declining foreign aid and restrictions on women’s economic participation remain major constraints.
• Foreign trade reached nearly $13.9 billion in 2025, but exports financed only around 15% of imports. Limited investment and inaccessible foreign reserves leave the regime with little fiscal capacity for welfare and infrastructure.

Erosion of International Isolation: 

• Taliban have sought legitimacy without undertaking meaningful domestic reforms. Nevertheless, realpolitik has weakened their diplomatic isolation. 
• Russia remains the only country formally recognising the Taliban government, while China, Iran, Central Asian states, Türkiye and Gulf countries have expanded engagement.
• Relations with Pakistan have deteriorated over border tensions and Islamabad’s allegations that Afghanistan shelters TTP militants.

India’s Pragmatic Engagement: 

• India has moved from initial caution to substantive engagement without formally recognising the Taliban. Following Afghan Foreign Minister Amir Khan Muttaqi’s 2025 visit, India upgraded its Kabul Technical Mission to an embassy.
• India-Afghanistan trade remains around $1 billion, while India has supplied foodgrains, medicines and disaster-relief material. Afghanistan is strategically important for India because of:
  • terrorism and regional security
  • Pakistan’s influence
  • China’s growing economic presence
  • access to Central Asia through Iran’s Chabahar Port; and
  • India’s longstanding goodwill among the Afghan people

Way Forward: 

• India and the international community should adopt conditional engagement, linking economic assistance and gradual normalisation to girls’ education, inclusive governance, minority protection and verifiable counter-terrorism commitments. 
• A multilateral donors’ initiative could support reconstruction while ensuring that assistance directly benefits Afghan citizens.

Taliban have delivered an absence of large-scale war, but not inclusive governance or sustainable peace. Five years on, Afghanistan remains at a fork between continued isolation and a gradual transition towards moderation and international acceptance.

PDF