Why in news?
After the leaders of the U.S., China and Russia met for a first-ever trilateral summit in Shenzhen on November 19, a Chinese proposal suggested calling the new world order the “Shenzhen International System”. This has raised a basic question for India: if the big three see each other as the only powers that matter, where does India stand? A recent opinion piece argues that India should lead a ‘fourth pole’ – not a single country, but a collective of like-minded nations.
UPSC Relevance
Mains, GS2, Bilateral, Regional and Global Groupings and Agreements involving India and/or affecting India’s interests
GS2, Effect of Policies and Politics of Developed and Developing Countries on India’s interests
Understanding World Orders
A ‘world order’ is the way power is distributed among states and the rules by which they deal with each other. A ‘pole’ is a centre of power strong enough to shape outcomes on its own.
| Type of Order | Meaning | Example |
| Bipolar | Two dominant powers with rival blocs | Cold War (USA vs USSR), 1947–1991 |
| Unipolar | One unchallenged superpower | U.S. dominance after the collapse of the USSR |
| Multipolar | Several centres of power, none fully dominant | Europe before World War I; the order India has long called for |
| Tri-polar (emerging) | Three powers treating each other as the only equals | U.S.–China–Russia after Shenzhen |
Why India Cannot Take its ‘Pole’ Status for Granted
For decades, Indians spoke of a multipolar order assuming India would automatically be one of the poles. The Shenzhen meeting shows this is not guaranteed.
- Economic constraints: India is a large economy, but low per capita income and rising inequality mean it will take long to be counted as a full economic power.
- Defence dependence: India remains among the world’s largest arms importers. Until it becomes self-reliant in defence manufacturing, its military power stays incomplete.
- Civilisational claims are not enough: Being one-sixth of humanity or the heir of an old civilisation does not automatically earn great power status. The idea of ‘Vishwaguru’ cannot be claimed – it has to be accepted by others.
- Status must be earned: As the author puts it, India can be “the friend that others are willing to be led by”. Influence comes from trust, not size alone.
The Proposed Action Plan: India and the ‘Fourth Pole’
| Pillar | What it means | Suggested steps |
| 1. A collective pole | A grouping of nations that values sovereignty, rejects expansionism and wants a say in decisions | Bring together middle powers from Tokyo to Brasilia that share the quest for strategic autonomy |
| 2. Diplomacy of conscience | Putting civilian protection at the centre of foreign policy | Firm stand against ethnic cleansing and mass civilian casualties; civilian-first mediation (e.g., Ukraine, Sudan, Yemen) |
| 3. Strengthen multilateralism | G20 and BRICS help build trust but cannot replace the legitimacy of the UN system | Host UN agencies; step back from the 2028-29 UNSC race in favour of Tajikistan; back the elected UNSC members on the next UN Secretary-General |
| 4. Defend international law | Push back against transactional politics and the weakening of global rules | Lead in signing and ratifying the Convention Against Torture and the Refugee Convention |
| 5. Nuclear balance | Prevent the three ‘foremost nuclear-armed powers’ from becoming sole arbiters of global security | Common rules on arsenal growth among like-minded nuclear powers; possibly a joint nuclear umbrella |
Not a new idea
The ‘fourth pole’ idea is not new in spirit. It builds on India’s long tradition of refusing to be part of any single power bloc.
- Panchsheel (1954): Five principles of peaceful coexistence agreed between India and China – mutual respect for sovereignty, non-aggression, non-interference, equality and mutual benefit, and peaceful coexistence.
- Bandung Conference (1955): Asian-African conference in Indonesia that laid the ground for solidarity among newly independent nations.
- Non-Aligned Movement (1961): Formally founded at Belgrade. Key founders were Nehru (India), Tito (Yugoslavia), Nasser (Egypt), Sukarno (Indonesia) and Nkrumah (Ghana). It has 120 member states today.
- Strategic autonomy / Multi-alignment: After the Cold War, India moved from staying away from blocs to engaging with all of them – Quad with the U.S., Japan and Australia; SCO and BRICS with Russia and China – while keeping its own freedom of decision.
The difference now is that India is being asked not just to stay independent, but to lead others who want the same.
Challenges in Building a ‘Fourth Pole’
- Diverse interests: Countries like Japan, Saudi Arabia, Germany and Brazil have very different security ties and priorities. Many are formal U.S. allies and may not want to look like a rival bloc.
- The China factor: Several Global South countries depend heavily on Chinese trade and investment, which limits how far they will go.
- Credibility gap: Leading on human rights treaties is hard while India has not ratified UNCAT or joined the Refugee Convention. Critics will point to this.
- Cost of sacrifice: Giving up a UNSC seat bid is a real loss of voice; the reputational gain is uncertain.
- Nuclear umbrella risks: A joint nuclear umbrella would conflict with India’s No First Use doctrine and could fuel an arms race rather than curb it.
- Capacity limits: India’s diplomatic corps is small for a country of its size, which limits how many fronts it can lead on at once.
Way Forward
- Build issue-based coalitions: Start with shared concerns – supply chains, climate finance, debt relief, critical minerals – rather than a formal bloc.
- Strengthen hard power at home: Push defence indigenisation and inclusive growth, since credibility abroad rests on strength at home.
- Lead by example on norms: Bring in a domestic anti-torture law and a national refugee framework to match words with action.
- Push UN reform steadily: Use the G4 and L.69 group to press for expansion of both permanent and non-permanent UNSC seats.
- Use mediation wisely: Offer good offices where India has trust on both sides, keeping civilian protection at the core.
- Voice of the Global South: Build on the Voice of Global South Summits and the African Union’s G20 entry to turn goodwill into durable partnerships.
A new world order is taking shape, but countries that were not at Shenzhen need not accept a role of only taking orders. India’s strength lies less in matching the big three and more in being a trusted partner for the many nations that want neither domination nor dependence.
UPSC Mains PYQ 2019 (GS 2)
‘The long-sustained image of India as a leader of the oppressed and marginalised nations has disappeared on account of its new found role in the emerging global order.’ Elaborate. (Answer in 250 words)
Practice Question
“A multipolar world does not automatically make India one of its poles.” In the light of the emerging great-power alignment, examine the case for India leading a ‘collective pole’ of middle powers. What challenges does such an approach face? (15 Marks)
Tell Google you want more of this.
Add Anantam IAS as a preferred sourceOne tap, and this site shows up more often in your own Top Stories, AI Overviews and AI Mode. Remove it any time.