Why in news?
A recent opinion article argues that nationalism in India is shifting from the inclusive civic model of the freedom struggle towards an ethnic one.
UPSC Relevance
Mains, GS1, Modern Indian History – The Freedom Struggle; Indian Society – Communalism, Regionalism and Secularism
GS2, Indian Constitution – Historical Underpinnings, Evolution, Features and Basic Structure
PSIR Paper 1 – Nationalism
What is Nationalism?
Nationalism is the feeling of belonging to a nation and the belief that the nation should have its own political community, usually a state. Scholars do not agree on how nations come into being.
- Benedict Anderson (Imagined Communities, 1983) called the nation an “imagined political community“. Members will never meet most of their fellow members, yet they share an image of their communion. Print capitalism helped create this shared imagination.
- Eric Hobsbawm pointed to “invented traditions” — symbols, rituals and histories created to give a nation a sense of continuity.
- Anthony D. Smith argued that modern nations rest on older ethnic cores (“ethnie”) with shared myths and memories.
The author adds that Anderson did not explore the possibility of many competing imaginations of a nation, where one imagination may dominate at a given time.
Two Forms of Nationalism
| Basis | Civic Nationalism | Ethnic Nationalism |
| Foundation | Shared political values – liberty, equality, justice, fraternity and faith in the Constitution | A single shared identity – religion, language, race or ethnicity |
| Membership | Open; anyone who accepts the political values and citizenship | Closed; based on birth, descent or culture |
| Attitude to diversity | Accommodates different religions, languages, food habits and cultures | Seeks to assimilate or sideline those outside the dominant identity |
| Source of loyalty | The Constitution and its institutions | The community, its history and culture |
| Common examples cited | France (post-Revolution), USA, India’s freedom struggle | Nazi Germany (Aryan supremacy); many 19th-century European movements |
The line between the two is not always sharp. Most nations mix civic and cultural elements. Political theorists also speak of cultural nationalism, which grounds the nation in a shared civilisation or heritage without necessarily denying equal citizenship.
Nationalism During the Freedom Struggle
Indian nationalism grew as a response to colonial rule. It was largely civic and anti-imperialist in nature — it had to unite people divided by religion, caste, language and region.
- It was linked to ideals of justice, equality, freedom and secularism, and to a scientific temper.
- It was also a democratic project — it demanded rights for all, not only freedom from the British.
- However, it was never one single voice. Several ideas of the nation competed with each other.
| Thinker | Idea of the Nation |
| Mahatma Gandhi | Nation as a moral community; Hindu-Muslim unity, Swaraj and Sarvodaya |
| Jawaharlal Nehru | Composite culture — “unity in diversity”; India as a palimpsest of many layers (The Discovery of India) |
| Rabindranath Tagore | Critic of the aggressive Western idea of the nation-state; favoured universal humanism (Nationalism, 1917) |
| B.R. Ambedkar | No true nation without social equality; fraternity must end caste divisions |
| V.D. Savarkar | Cultural nationalism based on Hindutva — common fatherland and holy land (Essentials of Hindutva, 1923) |
| Muslim League (M.A. Jinnah) | Two-nation theory — Hindus and Muslims as separate nations |
The Constitution as Civic Nationalism
The Constitution was the product of reasoned debate. It turned the inclusive spirit of the freedom struggle into law. Its introduction of fundamental rights was a big shift in a society marked by deep hierarchies such as caste.
- Preamble: Promises justice, liberty, equality and fraternity “assuring the dignity of the individual and the unity and integrity of the Nation”.
- Citizenship: Mainly based on birth, descent and registration — not on religion or ethnicity (Articles 5–11 and the Citizenship Act, 1955).
- Equality: Articles 14, 15 and 17 prohibit discrimination and abolish untouchability.
- Freedom and diversity: Article 19 (expression and peaceful assembly), Articles 25–28 (religion), Articles 29–30 (minority cultural and educational rights).
- Fundamental Duties: Article 51A(e) asks citizens to promote harmony and common brotherhood transcending religious, linguistic and regional diversities.
- Basic structure: Secularism and federalism were held to be part of the basic structure in S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994).
Ambedkar warned in the Constituent Assembly that without fraternity, liberty and equality would not last. This idea is close to what Jürgen Habermas later called constitutional patriotism – loyalty to constitutional values rather than to an ethnic identity.
The Author’s Argument : Changing Nationalism (PSIR)
- Shift towards exclusion: In the last decade or so, an ethnic and exclusionary nationalism has gained ground. Religious minorities, Dalits, tribals and women are pushed to the margins of the national imagination.
- Patriarchy and nationalism: Women are lectured on dress and conduct, and their public voice is seen as a “cultural shock” — showing a masculinised version of nationalism.
- Shrinking space for dissent: Labels such as “anti-national” or “urban naxal” are used against critics. Peace bonds are used to stop peaceful protests.
- Comparison with fascism: Citing philosopher Jason Stanley’s features of fascism (glorified mythical past, anti-intellectualism, victimhood, propaganda), the author argues some are visible today. Citing economist Prabhat Patnaik, he notes that Indian nationalism, unlike European nationalism, was anti-imperialist.
- Link with corporate capitalism: In times of economic crisis, capital needs an ideology that diverts attention from class issues and prevents the marginalised from uniting.
The Other Side of the Debate
These views are contested. Supporters of cultural nationalism and other commentators argue:
- Civilisational unity: India’s unity rests on a shared civilisational ethos that predates the modern state. Recognising this heritage does not by itself deny equal citizenship.
- Nationalism as a unifying force: A strong national identity helps counter separatism, insurgency and external threats.
- Constitutional framework intact: Elections, courts, a free press and federal institutions continue to work; minority rights remain constitutionally protected.
- Welfare reach: Government schemes are delivered on the basis of need, not identity, which supporters see as inclusive governance.
- Comparisons overstated: Many scholars caution against equating Indian politics with European fascism, since the historical contexts are very different.
For an aspirant, the key is to see the debate as one about which idea of the nation should guide India — and to anchor any answer in the Constitution.
Way Forward
- Constitutional patriotism: Make loyalty to constitutional values the core of national identity.
- Fraternity in practice: Build trust between communities through civic education, inter-community dialogue and local institutions.
- Protect dissent: Use preventive laws like peace bonds and Section 152 BNS narrowly, with judicial oversight, as dissent is the safety valve of democracy.
- Inclusive development: Reduce economic and social gaps so that marginalised groups feel an equal stake in the nation.
- Balanced public debate: Allow different imaginations of the nation to compete openly, without labelling opponents.
Nationalism in India has always been plural and contested. Its strength has come from its ability to hold diversity together. Keeping that inclusive, constitutional spirit alive is the real test for Indian democracy.
Practice Question
“Indian nationalism was born as a civic and inclusive project, but it remains a contested idea.” Distinguish between civic and ethnic nationalism and examine how far the Indian Constitution has institutionalised civic nationalism. (15 Marks, 250 words)
Tell Google you want more of this.
Add Anantam IAS as a preferred sourceOne tap, and this site shows up more often in your own Top Stories, AI Overviews and AI Mode. Remove it any time.